There is a wreck in Lake Ontario named the St. Peter. It lies in 110' of water off Pultneyville (east of Rochester, NY)....
This is from a fellow SB'er, describing it a bit:
............I think what happened is, that the guys that got to it first were making up stories to keep other divers off of it while they dived it every weekend taking whatever they wanted. The story goes that the ship was bound for St Catherines Ont. Weather turned bad and the ship turned around to return to Oswego Harbor. The ship went down off of Pultneyville. The Captain and his wife were clinging to wreckage. She couldn't hang on anymore, said her goodbyes and slipped beneath the waves. The Captain was rescued 5 minutes later. They say the shipwreck is haunted by Martha. The lake is always a little rougher in that spot. dive accidents, equipment failures, and injuries happen more often than they should, divers get bent for no apparent reason, and many get that feeling of the hair on the back of your neck standing and the feeling of someone watching you. I was there once. The Captain was sure he put us on the wreck. when we got down the line there was nothing there and we were dragging the anchor. Divers on the boat said we got blown off because Martha didn't want us there that day......
Haunted? You make the call.....