John, you are right. But I have also seen dive ops in MX that violate ratios and do not provide every diver with a light. That's why I tell people over and over again that they should know what the "rules" are, and make sure, when they call to make their reservations, that they are using an operator who follows them.
Couldn't agree more. It's been pointed out on more than one occasion that the cenote guides have an excellent safety record. But clearly there are, and always will be, people who make poor choices.
I know the "rules" say one guide for every four divers, but I don't know exactly what else is required. We did out cenote dives with a guide we'd dove with enough to trust. He's a full cave instructor. The five of us had about an hour drive to Chac Mool which was, essentially, an extended dive briefing. Equipment, signaling, separation (and why/how to avoid it), the meanings of the various colored lines (including which ones we would be following and which ones we would not be following) and gas management: all discussed at length. Alvaro dove in full cave gear, including doubles, long hose, and can light. Everybody had a light and a backup. I wore an Al 100 (a little more extra gas, just in case) and carried two backup lights.
I don't think the guy who grabbed my fin had been in a group that was quite as safety oriented...