sigelr:
We're considering a 1 week dive trip to Utila (Feb/Mar) and wanted to get opinions on accomodations, dive operators and of course on the diving. We're 4 guys more interested in great diving than great nightlife. We don't need super luxury but also don't want to stay anywhere that's too "rustic"! . This is an annual trip and we've been to Grand Turk, Cayman Brac, Cozumel and Bonaire in the past. The whole whale sharks thing and relatively unspoiled diving is appealing but certainly would want as much input based on experiences of others as possible. Any thoughts??
I dove in Utila for a few months from Aug-Oct and absolutely loved it. Had loads of great diving, brilliant small stuff, magnificent big stuff, and got less than an arms length next to two different whalesharks! Feb/Mar should be a great time to go from what I hear.
As for places to stay, there are many options, depending on your definition of "not too rustic". As someone else said, the Mango Inn is a rather nice accommodation, great pizzas at their restaurant, and they have a pool and bar. You get a discount there if you dive with UDC, so definitely worth checking out.
I dove at the Bay Islands College of Diving (if you're coming off the ferry dock, take a left and go 5 mins. to the fire station, same building). Great staff. I thought they had the newest and best maintained equipment, bigger and speedier boats, and I thought that they were good about paying attention to safety and technique. They also have the added benefit of having the Chamber right there on the premises, which although hopefully you are careful enough not to get bent, I found it interesting to check out. They have their own small pool on site, and a bar on the roof that is quite nice and has good happy hour prices. They also serve the Utila Lodge, which is also onsite. If you stop into BICD, then they can help you locate lodging that fits your budget and accommodation needs.
Be sure to check out all of the dive shops. There are something like 10 shops on the island, and since pricing is all standardized, your best bet is to check out the staff, equipment, boats, and services that each offers and choose the one that best fits your group's personality and diving lifestyle. I could literally find a reason to recommend each of the dive shops I think, depending upon the person.
I'm sure that it will be a hoot!