The rule in Bonaire which was concerning the original poster has had some positive results. Bonaire has some of the best looking reefs in the Carib. and yes I've seen a lot of it. Wether it's the fact that divers are more aware about their "space" or that fewer divers are actually hitting the reef I can't say. I do know that they try to enforce their rules and something is working for them. Go to the Caymans, grab a scooter and run the reef. You can tell when your getting close to a mooring ball by the condition of the reef. Cozumel has been so beat down it doesn't even come close to what it was just 10 years ago. I have video of the same sites for about the past 15 years, pictures don't lie. Belize is holding up OK but the liveaboards are starting to show there presence on the lower end of Lighthouse reef.
To wear gloves or not, well if the rules say no gloves then it's no gloves. I like wearing gloves for all the same reasons if I have to grab something I 'd rather not get a handful of hyroids. I had to provide assistance to a lady in Cozumel who was in respratory distress, she had brushed against a rope in the water and had an allergic reaction, so there are some "stingy" things that are better left alone. In Bonaire they put up a "Diamond Reef" bouyancy challenge. The PVC hoops are now covered with hydroids, better have good bouyancy skills or you get stung. I taught a "Peak Performance bouyancy" class and used the "diamond reef". I told the students we'd find out in hurry how good they were (joking here). As far as touching the reef versus kicking Mike F is spot on (as usual) however I think it might be hard to get someone to leave their fins on shore. Absolutley any damage to the reef is wrong but kicking everybody off the reef that doesn't have the skills that some of you are expecting might not sit well with some, or alot, of locals. I think as a whole we are doing a pretty good job of protecting the reefs, sure there going to some accidental damage, and as bad as that mey be we all are going to have to live with it. We all can try to make a difference. Mike F- keep pushing for better training stds. James G. stick to your guns and be a "reef ambassador" Natasha- have you tried acrylics? - no wait that's a different thread Indigo- thanks for the Hygene tips, I usually bite my toe nails, a bad habit I picked up in the circus. -M