This has been an interesting thread and I agree with the need to be fit, but I believe from what I have recently seen that mental fitness may be more important than physical in this case. On the dive my buddy freaked he was 15 years younger than me and in way better physical condition. I am 45 years old, overweight(working on that), am not in great physical condition(I sit behind a desk but am working on that). I had no problem at all getting to the bottom and doing my dive cause quite frankly my first dive out of Certfication was 110', spearing with no real buddy. I have probably 60 dives in less than 9 months many in poor conditionsand pretty much solo. Have I been a little freaked,yeah, in 1' vis by myself, listening to this booming sound I thought was a big Hebrew Mullet lurking just ought of sight. Turned out it was the boat trying to tell me to come up. Live and learn. Anyway, if ya want to bes afe ya gotta have your head screweed on right.