Students are more likely to buy what the instructor is using. If you care to maintain a good relationship with this particular shop (I have no idea if you do), it would be in your best interest to teach using stuff they sell.
If you don't care, then it doesn't matter. In either case, no "eye rolling" is necessary.
Terry
I suppose if the students have no other information, other than their own observations on what gear they should be diving, that would be true. If they receive adequate instruction on choosing gear that meets their needs, they can make an informed decision on choosing the gear that matches their needs and style.
"I bought cuz my instructor wears it" is a sure sign they don't have much of a clue about gear.
BTW, most of the gear (regs, bp/w, drysuits, mask, fins, gauges.....) I dive
was purchased from the LDS I instruct for. I have yet to hear of a student ordering a BP/W, Jets or a LH kit. I understand your statement, but it doesn't hold water in my experience.
Really? So getting to know people on the board, seeing dive histories and experiences, and getting consensus on what works based on those experiences....none of that is supposed to matter on the board?
Why have the board then if no one takes other peoples advice/opinion?
If I don't understand the reason behind the decision, I wouldn't be convinced if 95% of SB members endorsed something, but that's just me. If I'm correct about something, it's not because X number of people agree with me, it's because I'm correct. I couldn't find the poll OTW cited, either. But, if 70%-80% of SBers think back mounting a pony is a good idea for them, I'm not going to call that good enough and start back mounting a pony.
While I consider SB a great resource for getting a lot of different opinions, I do my own thinking. OTW's statement that he is right because of a poll on SB is an empty statement, imo. I had a DC a short time ago I'd never used before. He had is secondary routed over the left shoulder and I asked him about it. He'd been diving quite a while, but his response was "That's how the shop where I came from did it.". He had no idea why, but 100% of the folks from his home shop did it that way, so it must be right?