Dove with Papa Hogs last week and they are awesome. You dive to YOUR limit and ascend when it's YOUR time with your buddy. Fast boats with few divers. Their boats are painted black which is nice since all other boats are primarily white, it makes them easy to spot after you ascend. Excellent DM's (ask for Monkey) and Captains. For Mexico, reasonably on time. Majority rules on site selection... My wife and I were the last ones picked up everyday and It wasn't that the 4 divers that boarded the boat at Papa Hogs would make the decision without our input. After we boarded, Monkey would initiate the conversation on where we wanted to go. In fact one day, we were in route to Palancar Caves and half way there we changed our mind and wanted to do Santa Rosa wall so they turned the boat around and we did Santa Rosa wall. Another cool thing was one day my wife's computer wigged out and she had to abort her second dive. No fault of Papa Hogs, but they gave her a $20 credit for the aborted dive. Sorry, can't comment on requests for the extreme southern reefs or the northern ones but they are definitely eager to please so I'm sure they will make it happen. There are always exceptions though... on our last day we were with a pretty salty group of divers who had their daughter with them who had only 13 dives under her belt. For that reason some sites were off limits but not totally. We did Horseshoe, she stayed relatively shallow with one of her parents, dove 20 minutes longer then I did but we all have fun. I just hope that when I finally get to bring my daughter diving with me that I can find an accommodating operation as Papa Hogs and group of divers