Tourist dies in New Caledonia during a "Discovery Scuba" dive

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

jjhill

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Messages
137
Reaction score
18
Location
Alberta, Canada
# of dives
500 - 999
Quoted from Pacific Magazine link is here Pacific Magazine: Japan Tourist Dies In New Caledonia Diving Accident


"A 48-year-old male Japanese tourist who died on Tuesday in New Caledonia following a severe diving accident has been identified as a Matsumoto Hiroaki from Kobe, local radio reports.

Meanwhile, an inquiry has been launched in order to determine the circumstances surrounding what has been described as a rare diving accident.

Several witnesses have already been interrogated.

The accident has left the local diving industry in a state of shock.

Local diving club Nouméa Diving Manager Raoul Monthouël told local media on Wednesday the accident was all the more unlikely as every security precaution was observed, as usual, for this "beginner's dive."

This included a depth underwater not exceeding five meters, a maximum duration of 30 minutes and a very close watch from the diving boat. The victim was also diving with a certified Japanese instructor.

Monthouël told the local newspaper Les Nouvelles Calédoniennes the fatal accident could have been the result of a "moment of panic" on the part of the tourist, who had never dived before.

The victim was holidaying with his wife in the French Pacific territory, where he had decided to take his first scuba dive at the local Duck Islet resort off the capital Nouméa.
Initial reports after his emergency rescue and transfer to the local Gaston Bourret hospital intensive care unit indicate he suffered severe brain damage.

The accident took place after the diving party had resurfaced and was swimming near the dive boat.

The tourist, who was still wearing his diving equipment, including the air tanks on his back, first screamed for help and began drowning.

He was swiftly brought back to the small boat, then rushed by helicopter to the hospital.
He was pronounced dead about 24 hours later, on Tuesday afternoon.

New Caledonia has been, in the past fifteen years, a favorite destination for Japanese holidaymakers, especially honeymooners."

Not a lot of clear detail as it just happened, but tragic none the less.
 
screamed for help than started drowning? Wondering if he didn't inflate his BC, and just sunk from the weight?
 
Wow, what a sad way to go. Drowning from the surface after completing the dive seems so unnecessary and preventable. I've seen some horrible, horrible discovery scuba dives in tropical locales - the most barebone of briefings and instruction, DMs and instructors who are busy doing double-duty with OW checkout dives and guiding OW-certified divers on the same boat, etc. The whole "discovery scuba" program, at least as done in practice from my observation, seems like an invitation to disaster; it's almost never as highly-controlled as the selling points make it out to be, and people usually jump into the water without any real knowledge of the environment and the gear.
 
Could very easily have paniced, bolted and embolized. It's very sad.

My first thought, too.

It's very easy to trigger a survival instinct honed by 30 million years of evolution and very hard to prevent it with 30 minutes of instruction.

Dave C
 
hmmmm....missed the part where it said happened after the dive was completed. Man, I couldn't imaging going like that. My thoughts and prayers are with the family.
 
I don't know that part of the world. Are these two threads related? http://www.scubaboard.com/forums/accidents-incidents/254097-nusa-penida-bali-accident.html
Could very easily have paniced, bolted and embolized. It's very sad.
Those were my thots. Discover Scuba courses are like time bombs, altho I'm sure many Instructors are more careful than mine; I bet you are. I did 3 dives on my Discover Scuba in the Caribbean before certifying. Some quick explanations in 5 or 10 minutes on a dive boat, then to 40 ft. My third not-certified dive over two days was to 100 ft. Wrong, but happens a lot.
hmmmm....missed the part where it said happened after the dive was completed. Man, I couldn't imaging going like that. My thoughts and prayers are with the family.
A large part of the diving accidents happen on the surface after ascending. Have you ever dropped your weights since your OW class or orally inflated your BC after a dive? Good to practrice.
 
What is up with all of these DSD's I hear about in open water lately? I'm not going to claim I'm an instructor, expert, or any other authority on the matter, but a DSD in open water just doesn't make any sense to me. OW students need to complete several chapters of study and some pool sessions before going into open water, how do DSD's graduate straight to open water? I find it absurd to expect a DSD student to properly operate a BC, manage air supply, monitor ascent rate, or anything else. And, once again, where was the instructor?
 
Oh you're right I-dive, but in the world, it goes, as does para sailing, etc...
 
Folks,

I suspect these DSD "incidents" are more common than you think - where would be the obligation to report anything to DAN? As an example: my cousin (very athletic runner, good eater, etc. - all the things I'm not!) was vacationing on a beach in Thailand about 6 years ago. She say this guy with a "Yes, YOU can discover scuba diving!" sign and decided to try it. (She figured if I could do it, then she could, too. She just didn't know about the tests and hours of pool skills I had done.)

So when my cousin was descending, she had trouble equalizing. She signaled the "monitor" (I won't insult the instructors on this board by calling him an instructor) and he gave her a moment to try to equalize and then started dragging her deeper! My cousin was pulling back, trying to stay up (actually fighting this guy) when she heard/felt a "pop" in her ear and horrible pain. She jerked free of the guy and went for the surface.

I don't know how deep she was (and she doesn't either because she had no computer), but thankfully, she didn't get DCS or an embolism - and as we sadly all know from this board, you don't have to be very deep to do that.

When my cousin got back to Singapore (after a horrible flight with her ear), she saw an ENT doctor who told her the eardrum hadn't burst, but had been "bruised/slightly damaged" and so she could never scuba dive again. Even now, when she's snorkeling, she sometimes has problems.

But worse than that (well, from my perspective), for years now, I have had to put up with a load of cr*p from family members about how dangerous scuba is ("Look what happened to your cousin!")

So as far as I'm concerned, these DSD course are a waste and shouldn't be allowed. I think they may do more to harm the reputation of the sport than to create new divers. And if you doubt it, see the other post here about the guy in Hawaii - it was his THIRD DSD course - who "always meant to get certified, but never had the time".

Best to all,
Trish
 

Back
Top Bottom