Good point. I think you're right. You can do a pretty slow OOA ascent from 15 ft, but easier to control with 100# to work with.
If you were in deco at 130 ft, I think doing the best you can to get out of it on the ascent is good, but making the ascent without drowning is your first priority - then hope the boat's O2 bottle is ready. Seen a couple of failures on the latter but at least they were alive to deal with that.
Yep, could call it that way too. More air is always better for me.
This chart
Scuba Cylinder Specification Chart from Huron Scuba, Ann Arbor Michigan shows for Catalina tanks...
13: 4.38" OD 12.8" long plus valve 5.7# -0.8# buoyancy empty
19: 4.38" OD 17.4" long plus valve 7.8# 0# buoyancy empty
30: 5.25" OD 20" long plus valve 13.7# -0.2# buoyancy empty
As heavy as my 19 is to walk around with in the Santa Rosa NM parking lot with 7 mil suit & lead, or climb out of the water with, the 6# difference is small in comparison to the total load, but it all adds up. How much do you want to carry?
Most divers I know don't carry any pony bottle weight tho, so at least I got what I got with me. Have been glad a couple of times.