Boating accident in Fl Keys

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Update


Rescuers save 7 at sea
Woman, 80, died; girl, 4, spared
BY ADAM LINHARDT Citizen Staff
alinhardt@keysnews.com
[SIZE=+0]Snapshot charter Capt. Dan Jensen of Hawks Cay Marina was catching baitfish Saturday morning when he saw something in the water far off in the distance.
Minutes later, Jensen was on the radio reporting to the Coast Guard that he had picked up three men clinging to the bow of a partially sunken boat. His rescue launched a race to find rescue five other people from the same group, who had been in the water for 20 hours after their boat capsized off Long Key Saturday afternoon. The group had become separated in heavy seas.
Jensen talked to the national media about the rescue Monday, as authorities spent the day searching for the body of an 80-year-old Hialeah woman who drowned and investigating why the 22-foot Wellcraft capsized off Long Key.
The seven survivors -- three men, three women and a 4-year-old girl -- spent 20 hours in 4- to 6-foot seas enduring rain and thunderstorms.
"One guy swam to us, but the other two wouldn't leave the boat," Jensen said of the 8:49 a.m. Sunday rescue. "They said they didn't know how to swim, so one of my customers jumped in the water and swam to them."
One of the survivors recounted how he unsuccessfully struggled to keep his mother in his grasp, but Zaida San Jurgo was not wearing a life jacket, according to a Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) press release.
"They were Latino and luckily I had a customer on board who spoke Spanish, and from what the guy said, he was trying to keep her head above water," Jensen said. "At some point, she couldn't hang on and he couldn't hold on to her. He had to let her go. He started to tell us about it, but he totally broke down and couldn't talk."
About an hour later, rescuers found the other three women and a child hanging onto a floating cooler several miles from the partially submerged boat, said Coast Guard spokeswoman Lt. Kara Lavin. One woman and the child were wearing life jackets, Jensen said.
"I don't know how the heck they made it," Jensen said. "They're very lucky people."
The men appeared to be suffering from hypothermia and shock, Jensen said. A Coast Guard boat that pulled up alongside his took the men to waiting paramedics at Captain Hook's Marina Dive Center in Marathon, where the women and child also were taken by another boat. All the survivors were taken to Fishermen's Hospital, where they were treated for hypothermia, exhaustion and jellyfish stings, according to the FWC.
Jensen said the men told him the family had been coming to the Keys to fish for many years.
Their boat had been anchored near Tennessee Reef Lighthouse while the group fished, but the vessel broke free at some point, causing it to drift, FWC spokesman Lt. David Dipre said.
The boat capsized sometime around noon Saturday, but no mayday was broadcast, Dipre said. There also was no radio distress beacon on the boat.
"This was a really basic boat," Dipre said, adding that investigators were in the process of determining if the eight people aboard exceeded the boat's recommended capacity. "Being in that kind of vessel, in that kind of weather could lead to charges. We're still interviewing everyone."
Such cases generally lead to reckless or careless boating citations, depending on whether the boat operator was properly anchored or if he/she intentionally disregarded weather warnings, Dipre said.
The National Weather Service had issued a small craft advisory Saturday morning warning boaters of 20-plus mph winds, rough seas and heavy rain. The conditions had prompted Jensen to delay his trip while he waited for a better weather window. It was a stroke of luck for the survivors.
"If we had gone out earlier, I never would have seen them," Jensen said. "They got another hour or so of drift time, which put them in our sight line. When I first spotted them, I could barely see them."
The FWC did not release the names of those in the boat until their relatives were notified, Dipre said. The agency released the following names of survivors on Monday:

(Names deleted)
alinhardt@keysnews.com



Safe boating

Trtldvr
[/SIZE]
 
...the family had been coming to the Keys to fish for many years.
Their boat had been anchored near Tennessee Reef Lighthouse while the group fished, but the vessel broke free at some point, causing it to drift, FWC spokesman Lt. David Dipre said.

So, they weren't out for the proverbial "three hour tour"... Still, had no business being on a boat, in those conditions.
 
Besides the craziness of actually going out during this weekend's conditions I think the amount of people in this 22 foot vessel is worth at least a nomination in the Darwin awards.
My boat is just a hair bigger than that, and don't care to have more than 6 people on board. Only 4 if going diving.
So maybe the young and the old don't add a lot of weight but between coolers, fishing gear, grandma's chair and who knows what, 8 pairs of feet are too many in such a small boat.

If you look at the boat ramps in Miami, you will see that the rule of thumb is often one person per foot of boat length.:D
 
The family is about to appear on the Today Show. I am interested in hearing what they have to say and to see what kind of spin is put on this.
Yeah, since I've seen news articles with all sorts of variations on who wore life vests and who didn't. :idk: One story mention that some of the men were non-swimmers. :eek: But then, they hadn't bothered to learn the local language either.
 
Last edited:
No charges in deadly capsizing

BY ADAM LINHARDT Citizen Staff
alinhardt@keysnews.com
[SIZE=+0]No criminal charges will be filed against the operator of a boat that capsized in foul weather Saturday off Long Key, drowning an 80-year-old Hialeah woman, a state wildlife official said Wednesday.
Elena G. Gonzalez, 52, did not intend to be "willfully or wantonly" reckless by taking seven adults and a 4-year-old child fishing in a 22-foot boat in 20-plus mph winds and rough seas, according to Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) spokesman Bobby Dube.
Most or all of the boat's safety gear, such as life jackets, either were being worn or floated away when the Wellcraft boat capsized, leaving investigators no way to determine if there were enough aboard, Dube said.
Dube acknowledged that eight people was too many in a boat that size in such bad weather conditions.
"It's feasible that they were not over or just at the weight limitations of the boat," he said.
Investigators did not know how much anchor line was out when the boat began taking on water and how big a role, if any, that played in the boat capsizing, Dube said. The group was fishing in 25 feet of water near the Tennessee Reef Lighthouse when the boat took a wave over the stern. At some point the anchor line broke, sending the boat adrift before it partially sank.
In order for investigators to allege reckless boating, the boat must be under way, Dube said. The FWC had interviewed all the survivors as of Wednesday, he added.
The Monroe County Sheriff's Office dive team was out Wednesday searching for the still-missing body of Zaida San Jurgo, who was not wearing a life jacket, sheriff's spokeswoman Deputy Becky Herrin said.
"We thought maybe we could find her after looking at the drift patterns and currents, but it's a big ocean and we were unsuccessful," Herrin said.
Divers found the anchor, the anchor line, yo-yo fishing reels and some personal items such as wallets near the lighthouse, Herrin said.
The seven survivors -- three men, three women and a 4-year-old girl -- spent 20 hours in 4- to 6-foot seas enduring rain and thunderstorms before their rescue Sunday morning.
Snapshot charter Capt. Dan Jensen of Hawks Cay Marina, his first mate, Roman Butters, and five customers rescued the three men at 8:49 a.m., and the three surviving women and child were rescued by the Coast Guard shortly thereafter. The two groups became separated by currents.
All were from the Hialeah and Royal Palm Beach areas and have been coming to the Keys to fish for years, according to the FWC.
alinhardt@keysnews.com

Safe dives
Trtldvr

[/SIZE]
 

Back
Top Bottom