Bonaire critter
- Thread starter Kharon
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
R
redacted
Guest
The mark under the eye and the coloration suggest a Saucereye Porgy
drrich2
Contributor
All I can say is porgy, but if you do any online checking for photos to compare it to, let me say that diving Bonaire I observed porgies can change color, making the patterning go away leading a plain look.
Richard.
Richard.
OP
Kharon
Contributor
Yep - Jolthead Porgy - I never in a thousand years would have guessed from the picture in the book, but reading the description and careful cross checking of body parameters (including size) confirmed the ID.
Book description indicates possible "striped or bloched pattern, especially when feeding". I wish these fish would lean to conform to the published pictures and keep their coloration consistant.
Since they probably won't maybe Humann/DeLoach could include variations of common coloration for all the fish instead of just some of them. There are so many immature/juvenile/location variations that they include. Why, in their infinite wisdom don't they include common variations of adults?
Anyway, thanks for the ID. Guess I'll have to go from body shape and not color first. This is the second time the book has baffled me.
Book description indicates possible "striped or bloched pattern, especially when feeding". I wish these fish would lean to conform to the published pictures and keep their coloration consistant.
Since they probably won't maybe Humann/DeLoach could include variations of common coloration for all the fish instead of just some of them. There are so many immature/juvenile/location variations that they include. Why, in their infinite wisdom don't they include common variations of adults?
Anyway, thanks for the ID. Guess I'll have to go from body shape and not color first. This is the second time the book has baffled me.
unfortunately, all of the color phases can occur in most of the species.. nothing species specific about blotches or color. Really they only differ much in display markings on some males. So species IDs are tenuous.
Humann/Deloach cannot put multiple photos of every species without becoming three inches thick and twice as expensive-not their publishing model.
Humann/Deloach cannot put multiple photos of every species without becoming three inches thick and twice as expensive-not their publishing model.
Similar threads
