Does crunching plastic bottle attract sharks?

[Selachimorpha]

A friend of mine used this succesfully with Blacktips in the Bahmas. I have since used the crunching bottle on numerous dives with Bull Sharks and it worked every time (also had the occasional tuna coming to investigate).
I have yet to try it with any sharks here in the Red Sea, but will give it a go soon!

 

[Bubble Junky]

It's worked for me with grey reefs in Thailand, Sipadan & Palau......

 

[lemon]

I heard about this trick from my DM in Belize earlier this month while diving out at Gladden Spit. He said it is very effective at bringing in sharks and didn't want anyone trying it on the dives.

 

[Krazyklaws]

I've heard that using an empty bottle to 'pulse' water can attract sharks, although I've never tried it. As someone mentioned earlier, it's supposed to mimic an injured, thrashing fish.

A couple of taps on a tank with a knife worked like a charm in attracting hammerheads at Daedelus earlier this month though! They are very curious and come to see what's going on.

 

[DevonDiver]

I used crunching bottles to attract sharks in Thailand, Malaysia and Philippines. If sharks are in the vacinity, then it does a good job of bringing them into visual range.

My theory is that a crunch bottle might sound like feeding (chomping).

 

[RickI]

It worked in this case in Papua New Guinea caught on video, a bit too well it seems. Good thing for the diver the shark elected to rub the diver too while slamming into his face instead of taking a bite. Have others experienced a similar out of control reaction using the plastic bottle stimulus?

[video=youtube;zgclsxKrydI]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zgclsxKrydI[/video]

"Myself & my dive buddy were diving off Pidgeon Island in East New Britain Papua New Guinea. The two days previous we had been shark calling (rubbing a plastic bottle to create vibrations and sound that attract sharks) at around 30-40 metres looking for silver tip and grey reef sharks. We were pretty keen to see if we could get some bigger sharks and so decided to go deeper. I will point out that both of us are very experienced divers and fully knew the risks of diving so deep (and without the right kit too!). We descended fast down to around 57 metres, planning to spend no more than a couple of minutes there before continuing the rest of the dive as a deco dive. It was about 3 minutes into the dive when my buddy turned to see what he thinks was a big Silver Tip Reef shark (although there has been a lot of speculation as to what type of shark it was, maybe grey reef or possibly juvenile bull shark) charging in at him fast. He managed to roll over as the shark hit him and unbelievably he was unharmed. Apart from a severe headache (the shark actually hit him square in the head!) he was completely unscathed having not so much as a scratch on him. My buddy had said that when he saw the shark coming in at was going very fast but then slowed down just before hitting him, also it's mouth wasn't fully open and it made no attempt to bite. We think that what happened was that at that depth the shark would have been hunting and zoned in on the vibrations to go for a kill, upon realising we weren't food but a couple of idiot divers it turned round and went away.

I'd like to point out that my buddy (who is a dive instructor with over five thousand logged dives) has done this literally hundreds of times before in the area without incident as have a number of divers in the area over a period of years. What's different about this particular dive is that it is the first time it had been attempted by us below 40 metres. We knew the risks, we planned the dive and the deco time, we only had ourselves to blame if it all went tits up."