Former Instructor drowns practicing breath holding - New Zealand

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

DandyDon

Umbraphile
ScubaBoard Supporter
Messages
53,673
Reaction score
7,853
Location
One kilometer high on the Texas Central Plains
# of dives
500 - 999
Sad that he leaves his mom, wife, and two daughters at such a young age...

Static apnea is the freediving discipline that involves breath-holding while face-down and motionless in water. And the first rule drummed into freedivers is never to do this unobserved.

The reason for the caution is that things can go badly wrong even with such a simple pursuit, but Ant Clausen, 47, was alone when he tried to boost his breath-hold personal best, during a holiday from the UK to his native New Zealand.

Claussen had worked as a scuba instructor for six years in his 20s, before going on to become a professional freelance photographer and drone pilot, based in Liverpool.

Auckland coroner Alison Mills heard that Clausen, with his wife and two daughters, had been visiting family in January this year. His wife Natalia stated that he had been fit and a strong swimmer with no known underlying health conditions, according to a report on the inquest by the NZ Herald.

Having held his breath for three minutes the previous day, on 21 January Clausen told his wife that he planned to improve on that time, using the 2m-deep outdoor swimming pool at the apartment block where they were staying. He had even joked about the possibility of needing supervision for such a long breath-hold.

His mother later saw him in the pool and pulled him out unconscious. Natalia Clausen arrived about 10 minutes after last seeing her husband and applied CPR, but he was later declared dead at the scene.

Shallow-water blackout​

Based on a pathologist’s report, the coroner ruled that Clausen had drowned after experiencing a shallow-water blackout, brought on by holding his breath for a long period. His heart was found to have been slightly enlarged, which could have made his heartbeat irregular, leading to unconsciousness and, if submerged at the time, death.

“Shallow-water blackout often occurs without any warning and, without an immediate rescue, the swimmer very quickly drowns,” said the coroner. “Unlike a ‘regular drowning’, where there can be six to eight minutes before brain damage and death, there is only about two and a half minutes before brain damage occurs, then death, as the brain has already been oxygen-deprived.

“Repetitive breath-holding, however, increases risk of shallow-water drowning, as does hyperventilating prior to entering the water.” And she issued advice to others: “Never hyperventilate before entering the water, ignore the urge to breathe, swim alone or play breath-holding games.”
 
Tragic, but a poor understanding (or poor reporting) of what a shallow-water blackout is and what causes it.
 
Tragic, but a poor understanding (or poor reporting) of what a shallow-water blackout is and what causes it.
This would be a good time to explain.
 
This would be a good time to explain.
And I must apologize and stand corrected. I've always associated the term with what Wikipedia refers to as "ascent blackout"

Shallow-water blackout refers to loss of consciousness due to hypoxia during a dive associated with a shallow depth in differing causative circumstances. The following situations may be referred to as shallow water blackout:

  • Freediving blackout § Shallow water blackout, blackout which occurs when all phases of a breathhold dive have taken place in shallow water (i.e., where depressurisation is not a significant factor). The mechanism for this type of shallow water blackout is lack of oxygen expedited by low carbon dioxide levels, as a consequence of voluntary hyperventilation before the dive. Blackouts which occur in swimming pools are probably driven only by excessive hyperventilation, with no significant influence from pressure change.
  • Freediving blackout § Ascent blackout, loss of consciousness caused by lack of oxygen to the brain at the end of a deep breath-hold dive during the latter part of the ascent or immediately after surfacing. This is due to lowered oxygen partial pressure caused by a reduction in ambient pressure. Blackout in the shallow stage of ascent from deep free-dives may also sometimes be called "deep-water blackout".
 
what Wikipedia refers to as "ascent blackout"
Osmosis is not mentioned. Isn't there an exchange of CO2 going to the blood from the lungs and O2 being robbed from the blood to the lungs on the ascent? Not applicable in a pool drowning like this tho.
 
That’s so sad and entirely preventable. If anyone wants to push themselves with breath hold work please have a safety person watching and able to assist! Your body does not know how much oxygen it has!

I feel for his family 😢
 

Back
Top Bottom