By definition a hogarthian harness is made from one piece of webbing with one D ring per shoulder, no quick release and one D ring on the left waist strap and a crotch strap. A minimalist harness for a minimalist approach.
But having been around long enough to not be too concenred what other people think and also long enough to appreciate comfort and the ease of exiting after a long dive in cold water and a heavy dry suit, I prefer a quick release.
I also prefer the "pivot ring" style harnesses like the Dive Rite "deluxe" harness. I have found that the pivot ring keeps the strap from binding on the chest/shoulder/armpit and that a cross chest strap allows a good range of adjustment so I can go from dry suit, 7mm wetsuit, 3mm shorty to even just a t-shirt with out having to readjust the harness.
It's comfortable, covenient, gives up relatively little in terms of strenght, and I like it, but I'd never pretend it was a Hog harness either.