I finished my padi-e just last friday got to pool and OW dives on last sunday, we selected the instructor who talked us the best info on the phone I called two places on my vacation trip and the third was a little mom and pop shop they took a lot of pride in only working with people that want to dive my wife and I did the s*** out of that elearning reading everything we could, I do agree it was fast and you dont get any real live experience from that class its all on a website how can you, however my wife and I learn fast and we learn good. the instructor we selected I talked to on the phone for about 30 min prior to even signing up for the class and test and OW, once we got to the vacation spot we 1st thing went to our instructor shop we talked over everything and got all the info we didnt on the test (the elearning actually says to do that as well, also if the shop you are working with is on top of things they allow for online discussions and Q/A which makes it a little better)
but back to my feedback on the matter. Its all what you put into it that you get out of it. I had another guy with us who just wanted to get cirted because his family told him to, it was obvious he didnt care it came to dive table work and he said "no reason to learn this I have a computer that will do it for me" my wife and I were shocked.. this guy even sat thru a 3 day class NO e-learning he said he just didnt pay attention because the instruction in the class said if you use a computer you dont need this..
SO is e-learning better then a class of 30 students?
all depends on what you put into it to get what you want out of it. for me my instructor was AWESOME worked with us 1:1 in the pool to make sure we knew things small first then built on it.. as for the e-learning my wife and I learn good with computers (we are younger and thats how we learn to learn, with computers etc)
so be it elearning, XXXX certification, classroom, speed dive, all can dive.
If you dont want to do this, if you dont love to do this, if you dont care to learn you wont.
my only regret about elearning and diving is that I didnt do this 10 years ago!