Maui Dive Trip 9/25-9/29 Report

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Dolbie

Registered
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Location
Western Maryland USA
# of dives
25 - 49
My dive buddy and I recently returned from a quick trip out to Maui for three days of two tank dives. The weather was absolutely perfect for diving and we both had a great deal of fun.
Background:
Prior to this trip I had 5 dives in my logbook. I got my ccard in January 2008. My buddy has been diving for years and has ~150 recorded dives. He did a great job slowing himself down for me as I attempted to gain experience over this trip.

Day 1 - Maui Dive Shop - Molokini and Turtle Town:
I realized shortly after we departed from the dock that I had not even stuck my foot in the water since we got to Hawaii the previous day, so I wasn't sure exactly what to expect when I hit the water on that first leap from the back of the boat. The water was wonderful! As is my history it took me a while to get down to 30' with the rest of the pack due to my problems equalizing, but I eventually made it down with everybody. I didn't take my camera with me on the first two days of diving because I wanted to get more comfortable and avoid information overload. This was one of my better choices through the trip.
Molokini did not disappoint plenty of fish to watch. Before I knew it, it was time to go back to the boat.
It is easy to see where Turtle Town got its name. We saw five turtles (although I believe we saw the same pair twice and them one loner). We also saw a couple of Moray Eels and what I believe were some lion fish hiding in the folds of some coral (I'm still waiting to get copies of my dive buddy's photos). I got to last a bit longer on the second dive even though there was a little bit of a current. I must have been getting more comfortable and better at my breathing.

Day Two - Extended Horizons - Monolith and 2nd Cathedral
During our pre-dive briefing we were told that there were some impressive fish beyond the base of the Monolith formation. Our DM wanted to take us to ~110' to see these fish and asked if anyone was going to prevent that from happening. I couldn't raise my hand after that even though my previous deepest was ~65'. I tried to reassure myself by telling my buddy that if I could get past 40' I shouldn't have a problem with the pressure. I was right. I couldn't believe I was at 110' on my 8th recorded dive. I couldn't wait to call my folks (who encouraged me to get certified in the first place) and tell them about it. We saw some Bandit Angels and some other fish that our DM said would be there and a decent sized lobster way back in a crack in the monolith.
2nd Cathedral was another first for me. This is a lava tube and is a mostly enclosed area underwater. This time I spoke up in the pre-dive and asked if I needed more certification than I had to make this dive. Our DM assured us that even though the area was technically a cave type area, there are plenty of ways to get in and out and there was not a large amount of silt on the floor I'm guessing because the surge current. Inside was a very large and impressive Black Coral formation and a bunch of fish hiding in little pockets in the walls of the chamber.
One of the EH DMs, Victoria, gave me a hint for a breathing rhythm to try to extend my dive time which seemed to help a little on these dives.
I really enjoyed our two dives with EH. The capt and crew were great and their boat ran on Bio Diesel so they encouraged all us divers to go out and have a deep fried dinner so they could keep getting fuel from the restaurants around the island.

Day Three - Maui Dive Shop - Molokini and Red Hill
Our last day of diving had us watching the sunrise over Maui's East Peak and chatting up with the rest of the divers as we waited for the boat to get ready. I had also decided that I was ready to take my camera with me on these dives. After jumping in to the water near the eastern tip of the island where we were mored I dropped down to the bottom right along with the rest of the divers and had absolutely no problems equalizing on the way. After a minute of swimming along the bottom I was really happy I had decided to bring my camera because I looked to my left and spotted a ~4' White Tip Reef Shark resting on the bottom near our boat's mooring line. I may have been the 1st in the group to spot it because as I was swimming over to my buddy to tell him, our DM started banging on his tank and pointing to alert us. I snapped a couple of pictures which I wish could have been closer, but I wasn't too sad. I was thrilled to have seen my first shark on dive #10.
We had hoped that our 2nd dive would be over an artificial reef made of tires and to a wreck in about 65' of water but we were taken to Red Hill. This was a pretty good workout due to a strongish current. We saw some turtles, a huge male barely visible in the distance and a smaller female who swam right through our group. Everybody appeared to give the turtle plenty of space except for the boat's photo/videographer who did actually get some good shots and footage. I tried harder to use Victoria's breathing hint with the current and it seemed to help. My buddy and I were some of the last divers to return to the drag line for our three min safety stop.

I was so happy with how this trip turned out. I would certainly do it again if the opportunity presented its self. I think we both agreed that we would spend more time with Extended Horizons because the DMs seemed to practice better reef preservation techniques. To be honest, I had one fin touch the reef that I can remember and I did touchdown on sandy bottom on a number of occasions, but the MDS DMs were pushing off the reef with their hands and looking under rocks a bit more often than I thought was appropriate. This behavior more than anything made an impression on me.

I'll get some of my photos on this posting if I can. I am still getting used to using the camera while underwater so they're not the greatest. I also decided I need to get a strobe for my camera setup to light up my shots. Everything I took where the flash did not go off is completely green and I haven't been able to figure out how to nicely liven things up with Photoshop yet. So bear that in mind when viewing my photos.

2910594186_07e4015df4.jpg

On the way out to Molokini.

2909747769_18a76de8da.jpg

My first shark sighting.

2909747753_9059aed91f.jpg

Our everpresent escort around Molokini

2909747743_838e60cec4.jpg

This guy swam in front of me and posed like this long enough for me to get my camera out and snap this picture. Then he just swam off. I thought that was really nice of him. :)

2910594132_5d40e55b13.jpg

One of the many turtles we saw through the course of the trip.

2909747719_37cfcefac5.jpg


2909747689_c385ac54e3.jpg

There is actually a barracuda in there if you look REALLY hard.

2909747679_675296f4a5.jpg
 
.......Our DM wanted to take us to ~110' to see these fish and asked if anyone was going to prevent that from happening..............


This seems to be a frequent occurance in that part of the world. Bottom line is, you did a trust me dive, you came back and you had fun. I guess it is good your DM stopped at 110' and did not go to 140' like others. FYI though, you ALWAYS have the right to state your experience and comfort levels. If they were doing their jobs well, they would already know what your level was so it would come as no surprise.

Glad you had a good time and got what looks like some good dives in. Some day Hawaii will become a priority for me to dive. The list just happens to be way too long.
 
This seems to be a frequent occurance in that part of the world. Bottom line is, you did a trust me dive, you came back and you had fun. I guess it is good your DM stopped at 110' and did not go to 140' like others. FYI though, you ALWAYS have the right to state your experience and comfort levels. If they were doing their jobs well, they would already know what your level was so it would come as no surprise.

Glad you had a good time and got what looks like some good dives in. Some day Hawaii will become a priority for me to dive. The list just happens to be way too long.
Steve -- I know Extended Horizon's policies -- they would have insisted that *every* diver follow either a pre-calculated plan (using the RDP) or dive with their own computer (they offer to rent you one if you don't have one).

They don't tend to do "trust me" dives -- while you're right... the "trust me" dive is very common among most operators here, though every diver has the right (and is usually encouraged) to discuss any concerns with the DM prior to the dive.
 
Aloha Dolbie,

I am your aforementioned but unidentified Extended Horizons guide. As Chris mentioned, first dives with EH are a set profile and if you do not have a computer we rent them for $5 or you dive tables. Almost nobody choses not to spend the $5. It was actually Victoria who "wanted" to go to 110', I did mention Dolbie's limited experience as Eric, Victoria and I discussed our first dive site choice.

Monolith is the deepest dive site we visit. Current at other shallower sites is the reason we dove there this trip, and Dolbie's experience level was one of the reasons for us not wanting to dive in current. I got decent pics of the Bandit Angelfish. I was asking Dolbie his tank pressure often below 80', and he always responded in a way that indicated he was aware of the need for diligence.

P1010268C.jpg

Second Monolith is less than 100 feet from Monolith, and with the great vis that day we could nearly see the boat moored over Monolith from the deepest point of the dive. There is a hard bottom and no slope beyond that point so 120' is the max depth possible and you would have to go quite a bit farther away from Monolith to get there.

Longfin Anthias is the reason to go to 110', but only a couple divers in the first group got to see the male before he hid and my group did not see him. I have yet to get a picture of him. The other feature fish of this dive site is a Longnose Hawkfish in "his" Black Coral.

P1010271C.jpg

Second Cathedral does not qualify as a cave; 60' max depth with no point more than 40' from an exit, so less than 100' to the surface at all times. It is also a large space where only a couple short tubes are single file.

P10102851.jpg


P10102881.jpg


P1010295.jpg

The rare "White" Black Coral is the feature of this site, hanging more than 5' down from the roof. After exiting the cavern we also saw a "transitional" Longnose Butterflyfish, between the "black phase" and the normal phase (black jaw and dusky color).

P1010303.jpg


P1010304.jpg

Dolbie was down to his ascent pressure and heading to the mooring line in the final pic (if I have the right diver?), so he watched the Lobster and Stocky Hawkfish photo session from his saftey stop. Those and more picks from those 2 dives are at the link below.

halemano : photos : Mostly Second Cathedral- powered by SmugMug
 
I think we both agreed that we would spend more time with Extended Horizons because the DMs seemed to practice better reef preservation techniques. To be honest, I had one fin touch the reef that I can remember and I did touchdown on sandy bottom on a number of occasions, but the MDS DMs were pushing off the reef with their hands and looking under rocks a bit more often than I thought was appropriate. This behavior more than anything made an impression on me.

Mahalo for the kind words and my apologies for this shameless plug for my employer, the premier West Maui dive charter (at least in my eyes), Extended Horizons. :D
 
I'm a big fan of EH, but since you posted a link, I feel compelled to say, a serious web site redesign is way past due! :)

Mahalo for the kind words and my apologies for this shameless plug for my employer, the premier West Maui dive charter (at least in my eyes), Extended Horizons. :D
 
Halemano

a serious web site redesign is way past due

I agree :) These days, a good website is important as sometimes it is the first impression of a company.

Your dive photos were fantastic and it was nice to see you respond to this post to explain the situation. I have to admitt, readin his review had me a bit worried with the comment of "I hope is no one that is going to stop us from going to 110ft. Our Max FSW in Honduras was 105ft and when down there I was highly sensitive to how far we were from the surface :)

Dolbie,
Thank you for the nice review of the dive sites. It is great to get some fresh reviews as we prepare for our first trip to Maui. If you are using a Canon Poweshot Camera you may want to do some research on CHKD FW. It allows you to load a new OS on your Flash card and shoot RAW images with your Camera that would not normally support Raw pictures. Shooting RAW means you do not need to worry about setting white balance and exposure as you can change those in an editing program (Such as the Free Google Picasa)

Russell
 
Dolbie was down to his ascent pressure and heading to the mooring line in the final pic (if I have the right diver?), so he watched the Lobster and Stocky Hawkfish photo session from his saftey stop.

Hey, nice to hear from you and THANKS for the photos!

I hope I didn't come off sounding too preachy towards Maui Dive Shop. The staff on the boat and in the stores we visited were just great. Their dive skill was very good and the hospitality on the boat was nice too. I know that with under a dozen dives in my book I don't have much room to criticize. My certification instructor emphasized a super amount of care when it came to coral and other sea life. Since that is still so fresh in my mind I guess I reacted pretty strongly when I saw some of the actions of the MDS DMs.
 
I'd also like to address the 110' thing.
After how many dives should a diver make an attempt at that kind of depth?
While reading around on SB I've read a lot of replies to "When am I ready" questions that say "do it when you feel you are ready" (so long as it would not require additional certifications).
I have only had one slight freak out while under water and that was doing a resort dive years before I got certified. Our group was told to drop down the the sand bottom and wait for everyone to re-assemble. I was one of the first divers to make it to the bottom (about 25'-30') I looked up and saw 25'-30' of water between me and air and I had an "Oh $#|+" moment. This lasted for about 2 seconds before I remembered I had air with me and (checking my gauge) plenty of it.
After that I felt very natural under water and aside from my history of equalization trouble I haven't had trouble since.
I was excited and nervous at the chance to dive to 100'. I was also sure that if I changed my mind my long time friend and dive buddy would not have left me alone at the base of the monolith.
I knew that if I kept diving I would eventually get to 100' and I was very glad that I got a chance to do it in the waters off Hawaii rather than a cold quarry somewhere around here.
My buddy has already started talking to me about our next trip. Maybe we'll get to the Caribbean outside of hurricane season around May.
I can't wait for my next adventure.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/peregrine/

Back
Top Bottom