I did not realize that about domestic first class lack of club access. I only travel in first on a reward ticket or traveling on a company pass (I retired from Continental). Too much for me.
I try to use reward miles or buy a ticket for travel when I have a schedule to meet, which is usually the case for dive trips. I use the card for just about everything and auto pay it every month. The points add up.
Presidential Plus cards are no longer available for new subscribers, but those of us who had them prior to the conversion still maintain full Club membership, two free checked bags and elite access. It is a generous deal and worth the price if you fly often. My guess is they found it expensive and modified the benefits with the new cards.
When those cards first came out, I still had a year left on a 3-year PC membership so the card would have been redundant. After that expired, Continental offered J the PP card, waiving the first-year's annual fee. That was a really good deal! But our travel frequency waned and we didn't feel the cost of the PP card was worth it, so we let it go as soon as they wanted to charge the next year's fee. The club passes have been enough for me since then, as my domestic layovers are usually short enough to not worry about club access, and all my international flights tend to be in business class using miles, so I get club access on those.
I used this year's club passes in December in FLL on the way back from a cruise with a friend since we had several hours to kill in the airport. For my June flights to Coz, I'll be on the plane in LAX before the club even opens (5:15 am flight, club doesn't open until 5 am), then only 1:20 in IAH before the next leg takes off, barely time to deplane, traverse IAH to the departing gate, and grab a bite to eat before re-boarding. On the way back, there's no club lounge in COZ, and most of my 2 hours at IAH will be spent clearing customs/immigration, hopefully leaving some time for dinner at Pappadeaux's. Club access would be worthless for me, unless I just wanted to run in and out for a quick free drink. But I'll be flying in first so I can get my free drinks on the plane.
No kidding, the miles do add up. I used to use a Chase Business card for business purchases and racked up quite a few. After this "free" flight to COZ, I'll still have 733,000 left