Paya Bay is a beautiful resort- nice rooms, good food, wonderful hosts. They offer diving, but the waves in that area of the island can be rough and it is not always possible to go out with them (we have been trying to arrange a dive there everytime we go- never seems to work out!) The biggest problem for most people with Paya Bay is that it is very isolated from the rest of the island. It is on the East side off the main road (not paved here, but it is now kept in decent shape vs a few years back when the drive was a 4 wheel adventure!). There is no taxi service and little to do that is not at Paya Bay (or Camp Bay if you want to go to the prettiest beach on the island). However, if you truly want to be off the beaten path and at a beautiful, quiet resort, and don't need or want to go into town or need to do all the other island activities, try Paya Bay. They have a nice website to check out also.