I don't think I would take my kids to a first class resort.
My kids are good but they're just too young for it. Anyway, why would I want so subject them to boring stuffy resorts with lots of (for kids) weird rules when we can have so much more fun doing exactly what we want on our own terms? It's too cramping for the kids (for me too, actually), too much work for me and my wife to explain all the wierd rules and keep them reined in the whole time and too irritating for some of the other guests. Realistically, kids were put on this earth to teach parents how to deal with chaos and I can really understand people not wanting to join in the fun when they paid a lot of money to find some quiet, low-energy down-time. It's just a square peg and a round hole.
Anyway there's lots of time in the future to do the stuffy boring things with my kids once we've done all the exciting interesting things first
BTW we had the perfect vacation this year. 22 days camping in the wilderness. I dove a few days from a Zodiac in the absolutely astounding Sechelt Inlet (my old stomping ground) and my kids were free to play and laugh and explore in complete freedom without a single person snearing at them. Ever see two 4 year olds play "jungle explorer" in the forest for an entire day? Those are the things you became a parent for, not to sit around and whisper 'shhhhhh' to your kid all day long. And for me and my wife, God's garden wins hands down from the best resort on the planet. Full stop. Next year we're planning something similar.
I remember when I moved to Holland my mother said 'you'll miss camping...' and my father said "don't worry....you can take the boy out of the mountain but you can never take the mountain out of the boy." and he was right. Next to diving, camping is the thing I most love to do. In a way, living in Holland, where the only remaining signs of untouched nature are found under water, has strengthed both my love of camping and my love of diving. And I'm blessed with children who have this spirit too.
R..