Doc Intrepid:Thats two reg switches that must be made using independent doubles that need not be made if using a manifold.
That's "more complex".
Start carrying two deco bottles, get involved with some unscheduled excitement, and that requirement adds task loading. Added task loading is seldom a desirable benefit from any equipment configuration.
I don't see that. If the feces hit the fan you only task is to find breathable gas. If you planned your reg switches you will have adequate gas to return to deco stop following rule of thirds. No need to access any more gas than the amount you came in with.
Remebering to switch regs is automatic after a while. Like saying driving a standard vehicle is task loading. You just don't think about it happens.
Ever dive side mount?Doc Intrepid:Depending on what sort of dive it is, e.g. whether you're in an overhead environment, whether you've staged bottles, or you've built up a deco obligation, if something happens to one side you may not have access to any of the remaining gas on that one side.
rule of thirds with independant:Doc Intrepid:If something happens on one side to a set of manifolded doubles, you generally still have access to the entire quantity of backgas through the other post. Depending on where you are when you have the problem, what sort of dive you're doing, you might need access to all your remaining backgas.
1/3 tank A switch to tank B then breath 1/3, turn dive continue to breath tank B until 1/3 remain then switch to tank A again and breath remaining 1/3. If no drama occurs you end up with 1/3 in each tank. If SHF you lose one tank you end dive with both tanks empty but alive. I am so used to this method that I close my isolator when diving manifolded doubles. I have tried the other method. Maybe you should try mine Doc