Photo-related MacBook vs PC question

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

...
Here's how I use my computer
  • Internet
  • E-mail
  • Photo viewing, editing, and storing (PS Elements, Nikon Capture NX, ACDSee)
  • Making photo slideshows (Proshow Gold - would consider installing Windows XP and using Windows with Bootcamp on the Mac)
  • Ripping and storing CDs
  • MS Office documents (Word, Excel)
I'm not really sold on the helpful lifestyle programs that the Mac comes with. I don't care about video chatting, garage bands, or making DVD movies.

Compared to comparably spec'd Windows computer, the Macs seem really expensive, so I need a good reason to go down that road.

Why would I buy a MacBook Pro over a MacBook? They seem very similar except for speed, memory, harddrive size, and screen resolution (yes I know, those are the most important specs). Is there any other difference between a Pro and a standard MacBook?
David

I'll preface this by saying I will not get into a religious argument.

However, many people who seriously compare equivalent hardware believe
that macs are competitively priced with name-brand Windows machines.
It's certainly true that you can get a lower-end PC for a lot less than you can
get the cheapest mac for, and you may not want all the extra hardware
features and name-brand quality that come bundled in a macbook. But apples-to-apples
(the pun is irresistible) mac hardware is not really much more expensive.

If you might consider a mac, and want the second part of your question
answered: The macbook pro adds value in compute-intensive tasks, and
most particularly graphics, like games and video editing. Unless you're
doing it all day long, the difference for still photo editing probably isn't
worth the added cost. Here's a very informed and fairly detailed comparison
based on the newest macbooks, which have caught up somewhat with the
macbook pros. at least for the time being:
In black and white: a review of the Santa Rosa MacBook: Page 1

One other thought: If you go mac, skip Office, at least to start. Neooffice is
a mac-customized version of Open Office - free, and very, very, compatible
with Office for word and excel use except for the ultimate power users.
You can always buy Office for mac later if Neooffice doesn't measure up,
but I'll bet it will.

As for a good reason to go Mac - how about Windows? That's enough for me.
Again, there are thousands of mac vs windows fights on the internet every
day, and I won't get into one. I just wanted to challenge what I believe is
an incorrect statement about hardware cost that everyone was nodding their
head over, and point to the macbook vs macbook pro info you asked for.
 
If you do get a new pre-packaged PC, be careful because it will probably have Vista on it and changing the operating system will void the warranty. Unlike most previous versions of windows, Vista is not compatible with many programs that weren't designed for it. About 80% of my programs that I got for XP (photo/video editing, camera drivers, etc.) don't work with Vista and there are no updates available.
 
If you might consider a mac, and want the second part of your question
answered: The macbook pro adds value in compute-intensive tasks, and
most particularly graphics, like games and video editing. Unless you're
doing it all day long, the difference for still photo editing probably isn't
worth the added cost. Here's a very informed and fairly detailed comparison
based on the newest macbooks, which have caught up somewhat with the
macbook pros. at least for the time being:
In black and white: a review of the Santa Rosa MacBook: Page 1

Thanks for the link and advice about NeoOffice. I've found it to be interesting reading.
 
I appreciate everybody's opinions and information. Keep it up. I'm looking to be seduced by Apple, but its not happening yet. Vista makes me a little nervous. Still, I survived every version of Windows since it was first created (and usually the newest versions came with dire predictions), so I figure I'll survive Windows if I go that way. I'll compare the hardware costs. I don't believe that they are similar, but we'll see. Part of the price inequity might come from the fact that PC notebooks can usually be found on sale and Macs are never on sale (from what I have seen).

Right now, I'm drinking a Christmas Ale from Anchor brewing company. Its very tasty. Pick some up the next time you're at BevMo.

David
 
I have a 15" MBP and I am an engineering student. So, there are lots of programs (CAD, etc.) I need to run that are Windows only. I installed boot camp and XP and it worked very well! Not a problem with the programs. I was impressed.

Here is what I would say: If you like the mac, but can't get away from windows, buy a mac, install XP on another partition (using boot camp) and now you have a mac and a PC. You can do all the old PC stuff, but also have the Mac for general use and photo stuff.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom