Rare Catalina Shark Attack

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Have you guys noticed that non-divers always talk about sharks whenever there is any mention of diving?

A lot of people have no idea how common (or not) potentially dangerous sharks are in the ocean.

In a related example, if you watch nature shows on t.v., you might get the idea that on a casual stroll through the forest in the southern U.S., one might see raccoon, foxes, coyotes, skunks armadillos and what-not strolling around. Spending considerable forest time in Arkansas, I can say that of those, an armadillo or skunk up during the day would be a rarity, no way would I see a fox, coyote or bobcat (much less a black bear, mountain lion or wolf), and I might see a rabbit, deer or squirrel, lizards, birds, perhaps a snake. But nothing like you'd see on a nature special.

Now consider the historic portrayal of sharks as near-mindless eating machines. The assumption would be that those considered dangerous (great whites, tigers & bull sharks; perhaps a few others) are large, powerful predators who pretty non-discriminantly attack & kill whatever they can catch that's substantially smaller than they are (rather like a frog or toad eating whatever fits in its mouth). Stories of human-made litter like license plates showing up in shark stomachs reinforces the 'they eat anything' mindset (Tiger sharks have particularly been characterized this way I believe). And the oceans are connected, so there's no reason to believe these sharks are geographically isolated as land animals are. I can walk in the woods in Kentucky with little fear of African lions or Indian tigers, but is there really any reason a great white couldn't nail me off Bonaire?

Great whites are a lot more prey-specific and intelligent than is commonly realized. Being cooler water sharks who as adults favor marine mammals they seem to be rare in some of the mainstream dive locales like Cozumel, Bonaire & Grand Cayman.

So the average citizen, having seen some shark horror movies & shows discussing real shark attacks, considering being eaten alive floating screaming in salt water being a horrible death, and with the ignorance cited above, views them as a danger.

If I went to rural Africa and a villager invited me to stroll across a grassy savannah, I'd at least ask about the potential danger of lions, leopards, cobras, etc...

Richard.
 
Ask them how many divers have been KILLED by sharks here over the past 50 years, then how many drivers have been killed driving the freeways of "Lost Angeles."

Personally I find it hard to call this incident (or the one with the woman in the kayak a few years ago) "attacks" on humans. They were cases of mistaken identity in which the shark thought the board or kayak looked like a marine mammal or something else that might be yummy. The sharks did not target the humans on board... that would be a real attack. Of course, if in the process of attacking the board or kayak the shark maimed or killed the human, semantics wouldn't matter.


My understanding is it's been only one diver (abalone diver) killed by a shark in 50 years in So Cal. Do you have any different info?
 
My understanding is it's been only one diver (abalone diver) killed by a shark in 50 years in So Cal. Do you have any different info?

I can't give a specific number without further research, but yours sounds accurate enough. It is such a rarity for an incident involving a diver here, although swimmers, kayakers and surfers "encounter" more of them.
 
I can't give a specific number without further research, but yours sounds accurate enough. It is such a rarity for an incident involving a diver here, although swimmers, kayakers and surfers "encounter" more of them.


I might be wrong but I think I heard the "only 1 diver killed by a shark in So Cal in 50 years" from Ken Kurtis.
 
I tried to find as much as I could a couple years ago (after shark week of course). I found only 6 instances of divers (including snuba) being killed by sharks. If memory serves, all 6 were hunting (spear fishing or abalone). I don't do either so I'm okay with the odds.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/teric/

Back
Top Bottom