I had this same conundrum and ended up with three different lights to test
Dorcy 220 lumens wide angle
hog pigtail I think about 120 lumens?
piranha dive live manufacturer 130 lumen small light
Of these the Dorcy 220 wide angle works the best for me because of the wider beam and more powerful lumens, although all were bright enough for night diving. For the day time I am thinking about getting a DRIS 1000 lumen shorty as none of these really worked for crevice hunting or highlighting, but that would be way overkill for Caribbean night diving IMHO. I like the push button feature of the Piranha one a lot and didn't like the screw on/off of the others although I got use to it.
Just my two cents....
Dorcy 220 lumens wide angle
hog pigtail I think about 120 lumens?
piranha dive live manufacturer 130 lumen small light
Of these the Dorcy 220 wide angle works the best for me because of the wider beam and more powerful lumens, although all were bright enough for night diving. For the day time I am thinking about getting a DRIS 1000 lumen shorty as none of these really worked for crevice hunting or highlighting, but that would be way overkill for Caribbean night diving IMHO. I like the push button feature of the Piranha one a lot and didn't like the screw on/off of the others although I got use to it.
Just my two cents....