That is a really good question and one that I am asked often, first you are probably going to love both islands. Statia is known for the diversity of dive sites with 8 distinct ecosystems, and Saba has spectacular underwater pinnacles. I would say if at all possible try extending your trip, most guests really aren’t ready to leave after just a few days and there is plenty of diving to be had. That being said Statia’s dives are shallower so more bottom time and there is so much to see so more time on Statia in my opinion. Keep in mind I want you to come diving with me on Statia, so look into both and decide for yourself. Also you don’t lose a day on travel between islands as the flight never gets above 1,000’ and only last 8 minutes. As for which one first, up to you if you’re a little rusty Statia first as the dives are less challenging and Saba last for the grand finale. You could also see it the other way around get your deeper dives out of the way in Saba and then go for bottom time on the shallower dives in Statia, either way you’re a winner!!
Glenn