Dear Groundhog,
You make several good points on what is provided and it's value, ridiculous is too strong a word when suprise would be more accurate..
I guess what bothered most of us who have been going up there for close to 20 years was when you looked at it from a percentage point of view as it jumped from $8 to $15 ( 90% )which has some pretty good shock value and seems punitive to divers.
(On a side note - lots of non paying tourists use the bathrooms-not just divers, the glass bottom boat and dive charter operators aren't taking people for free and I have never seen park wardens out in scuba gear gaurding the wrecks from souvenier hunters - I rarely see them at all.)
FYI - The comments we have been hearing from a lot of experianced divers in casual conversation is that it is just another reason not to go to Tobermory. ( it's not fair but people are saying it)
Perhaps it is just an image problem, but combine that with a long drive from the GTA, very cold water and some would argue poor wrecks compared to Kingston or Brockvile ( not me - I love the Arabia) and it could be a problem for the town of Tobermory.
Just some thoughts...