Apnea diving question

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Roak-

oops, looks like I suffered an AWB (Above Water Blackout) when I wrote this...well, that's what you get for stayin up too late.

Working here in China, I am always amazed that the laws of physics still seem to work...elsewhere..:)

I appreciate all answers, this question has really been bugging me.

Ah, I need to get back in the water...later.
 
This was recently posted on the freedivelist. I've been trying to get permission to repost it but exact ownership is a bit vague, Ron Mullins supplied the article to the FDL. But I thought it might be of interest here, maybe the docs can comment on the details

Ralph

****************************************************************

Pulmonary barotrauma:

In order to understand what happens to the lungs during a breath-hold dive, it is necessary to introduce some basic concepts about the structure of the lungs and how gas-exchange takes place between the air in the lungs and the blood.

Basic lung structure:
Beginning with the main windpipe, the trachea, the air passages divide repeatedly into branches for up to 20 generations (divisions), eventually ending in tiny blind sacs, the alveoli. These alveoli are very small (100-300 µm in diameter) and have very thin walls of about 10 µm , known as the alveolar septa. Blood flows through the the alveolar septa in very thin-walled blood vessels known as capillaries that are 10-14 µm in diameter. This has the effect of creating an enormous surface area (approximately 100 square meters) for gas exchange to take place between the alveoli and the blood (oxygen from alveoli into the blood and carbon dioxide from blood into the alveoli). The heart ensures that the body¹s entire blood volume of about 5 liters flows through the lungs every minute while at rest. During exercise this flow may increase to as much as 15 liters per minute. Air flow in and out of the lungs is generated by the diaphragm and the muscles of the rib cage acting very much like a bellows.

Changes in lung volume during a breathhold dive:
As a diver descends, the surrounding pressure (ambient pressure) increases, exerting pressure on the body, including the chest. The rib cage is compressible, so it decreases in volume, compressing the air in the lungs according to Boyle¹s Law. The volume of the lungs is additionally decreased by ambient pressure compressing the abdomen, forcing the abdominal contents towards the chest. Eventually, at about 25 meters for most people, the chest reaches its limit of compressibility and becomes very stiff. At this stage, the delicate alveoli are OK, because the pressure within the alveoli is the same as the ambient pressure, so that no distortion of the basic alveolar structure occurs.

However if the diver descends further and more pressure is exerted on the body, the air within the lungs is no longer compressed, because of the stiffness of the rib cage. What now happens is that a pressure-difference develops between gas in the alveoli and the rest of the body. Blood is now forced into the blood vessels of the lungs and the thin-walled capillaries within the alveolar septa become swollen with blood, leak and eventually rupture so that blood and fluid escape into the alveoli. This eventually finds its way into the airways and is coughed up. The alveolar septa can also swell with fluid (oedema) resulting in thickening of the septa and impairment of gas exchange (particularly oxygen). This oedema, plus the irritation caused by the bleeding into the lung tissue and airways leads to the discomfort and shortness of breath that follows and which may last for hours or days. In severe cases death ensues. The phenomenon is generally known as "lung squeeze", or in medical terms, pulmonary barotrauma.



Is the depth at which lung damage occurs predicable?
If a person takes a maximum deep breath, the amount of air in the lungs is known as the total lung capacity (TLC). If he/she then exhales to the maximum extent, the amount of air that remains in the lungs is known as the residual volume (RV) . The RV is normally about 25% of TLC. Furthermore, the chest wall usually reaches it¹s limit for compression at RV, so using Boyle¹s law, it is possible calculate the theoretical limit to which a diver can descend without danger of lung squeeze if it is assumed that the diver takes a maximum deep breath at the surface. It works out that the average diver¹s lungs will be compressed to RV at 30 meters in sea water. In fact, in some young men who have very compliant chests and perfectly elastic lungs RV is only 16% of TLC, so that they theoretically, could descend to a depth of 6 atmospheres or 63 meters. In recent years breath-hold divers have descended to more than 100 meters and this could only have been achieved by an additional mechanism that comes into play, namely that blood is shifted from the organs and large veins in the abdomen into the large veins of the chest. This helps to reduce the volume of the thoracic cage, thereby compressing the lungs further. It has been calculated that at such depths about 50% of the surface RV must be filled with blood. Experimental findings indicate that the intrathoracic blood volume is probably increased by a liter at 70 meters.

Diving mammals achieve even greater depths to more than 300 meters. These animals have very flexible rib cages and a huge ability to shift blood into their chests. They also have very large blood volumes as compared to man on a liter-per-kilogram body weight basis.

Implications for ordinary mortals who do breath-hold dives:
… If a diver experiences lung squeeze, he should not persist in diving to those depths. If he does, he runs the risk of not only repeated permanent damage to his lungs, but also of an episode of severe generalized lung oedema and haemorrhage that can be fatal.

… Always begin the dive with a maximum inspiration (i.e. at TLC). This gives the maximum range of compressibility for the rib cage. Theoretically you will develop lung squeeze at a shallower depth if you take a small breath before diving.

… Avoid movements of your diaphragm while under water. Diaphragmatic movements (especially inspiratory movements) can lead to greater pressure-differences between the alveoli and the ambient pressure, resulting in greater engorgement of the capillaries.

… Older divers must realise that as their rib cartiledges becom calcified, their rib cages become less compressible and in addition, the aging lung develops a greater RV. The TLC/RV ratio therefore becomes smaller and theoretically they will develop pulmonary barotrauma at shallower depths.

… Other than the techniques described above, no amount of training is going to lessen your risk of pulmonary barotrauma. If you have any other pet theories, forget them they are merely wishful thinking.

… The average medical general practitioner or even many lung specialists are not aware of the mechanisms or the dangers of pulmonary barotrauma in breath-hold divers, unless they have a special interest or have received special training in diving medicine. (Diving medicine is not included in the pre-graduate medical curriculum).

… I surmise that for visible blood to be present in the sputum, probably thousands of alvoeoli have sufferred fluid swelling and bleeding into the alveolar sacs.



Johan Coetzee Feburary 2004.
 
Thanks for Coetzee's info. This is highly specialized physiology, indeed.

To be honest, I wish it (freediving in general) weren't publicized so, and even glamorized. I believe others may obsess with record setting and all, risking their lives.... Mt Everest continues to entangle dreamers. For my sake, I am just curious about the science.

How do these divers get down and ascend, timeframe, equipment, etc. Are they weighted?

I can't imagine the divers can expend so much energy, consume O2 and accumulate CO2 as a byproduct (swimming like hell). Do they go down weighted, then drop weights and ascend by (nuclear powered) fins? Do they start by breathing enriched air to their TLC? Do they develop efficient "mammalian diving cardiovascular reflexes (bradycardia, centralizaton of cardiac output)" by practice or is this trait selected in this community?

At depth, they gain because they can extract O2 since the ppO2 rises. I can imagine that upon ascent, O2 reserves are depleting, and then closer to surface (at approx. 2 min timeline) that their ppO2 becomes hypoxemic, and/or alveolar hypoxia occurs due to hypercapnea, and /or hypercarbic narcossis occurs -- any of which leads to unconsciousness, drowning and death. "Pulmonary barotrauma" could compound O2 diffusibility as well.

[Inspiratory effort against a closed glottis would also lead to non-cardiogenic pulmonary edema and present the same, indistinguishable scenarios "pulmonary barotrauma" mentioned above]
 
wetnorm,
you've got it all figured out it seems.. really. There is no enriched air involved, no nuclear powered fins, there is no "race" to the bottom, it is methodical, efficient, dreamlike when best. Training/conditioning helps. The body is quick to condition itself to the sensations of repeated buildup of CO2. Learning to do a good breath-up extends the breathhold times quickly. Listening to what your body tells you on dryland while practicing apnea and than staying a long way from your limits under the water is also good idea. To learn more about how a freediver gets down and back again, there's tons of info on the net under google. Here's a timeline now for you: the best of the freedivers is finning down and back up again to a depth of about 301' and doing it in just over 3 minutes. Sorry I don't know the exact times. 3:09 or maybe it was 3:20, but close to that. The "now" purest form of freediving is without fins, and still in my book the most diluted form of freediving is riding a sled down and returning with a balloon. So many different disciplines: constant ballast, variable ballast, free immersion, no-limits, and the list goes on. And here's a thought for you, it's really about being able to equalize first and foremost, then about being comfortable under the water on a breathold, then about moving efficiently, and lastly about being able to hold your breath.
 
HMyB,

What do you think is the attraction to freediving?

The challenge; personal achievement? Like running, setting your own times/depths records?

You can "see" much, or least see for as long a time as I enjoy seeing "stuff" (reefs, fish, critters, wrecks, etc) when using SCUBA.
 
wetnorm,
different fdivers are attracted to the sport for different reasons I suspect. Some spearfishermen, because of laws, have no option but to freedive rather than scuba, some fdivers, like some sdivers, need to set records, and I imagine, some fdivers, like sdivers, like to defy nature by going under the water. Kinda for the thrill. I hear some fdivers talk about it as if it is a religious experience, getting into the zone, probably not unlike a runners high.
Personally, I can't pinpoint the reasons I love to fdive. If I were to say; this reason or that reason is why I like to fdive, then in the next instant of my thought I have yet another reason. Can't explain it. I know I'm addicted.
then there's always the standard quick answers: no bubbles, no noise, closer to fish, during a day of diving not being limited by nitrogen buildup and so being able to spend more bottom time then on air, no 24 hour fly rule, totaly un-encumbered diving, easier suiting up, give me a pair of fins and a mask, no need for c-cards $$, the list goes on...
 
wetnorm:
HMyB,

What do you think is the attraction to freediving?

The challenge; personal achievement? Like running, setting your own times/depths records?

You can "see" much, or least see for as long a time as I enjoy seeing "stuff" (reefs, fish, critters, wrecks, etc) when using SCUBA.

For starters I guess...It's illegal to spearfish with a gun or on SCUBA in the bahamas. You have to be freediving or as most of the freediving world knows it, apnea diving, and using a Hawiian sling.

But your other attibutes to apnea diving are some of the reasons I'm in it. Personal Challenge, enjoyment, spearfishing legally, etc. etc.

http://www.aidausa.org/index.html
 
Thanks....free = apnea diving!!!; Although, I didn't know anything was free about the ocean. To me (naive me) I always called this snorkeling; and knew my personal limit was 15-20 ft. I never needed to go lower than this in the So. Fla waters.

After spending a small fortune on my hobbies, I can better understand looking into any sport involving the seas (which I am obsessed about - boating, sailing, SCUBA, reef tanks, whatever) which is "free..." Lame pun, I know.

But more than this, I can appreciate the joy in simplicity, especially the absence of anxiety which involves mastering any complex art that involves personal danger.

As a kid, I snorkeled for years of Miami Beach, Key Biscayne, Pennekamp and I know that this is where my enjoyment really started.
 
Bubble free....Just soaring thru H20 with nature. No loud sometimes clanky equipment involved unless you have a metal gun. But best of all, it's not for everyone. The field is still small and "know it all" free...at this point. As a kid I snorkeled Jax, then mostly Boca Grande, Venice and Naples....Shallow fun. Occasionally we would do Largo thru Marathon.
 
wetnorm:
Thanks....free = apnea diving!!!; Although, I didn't know anything was free about the ocean. To me (naive me) I always called this snorkeling; and knew my personal limit was 15-20 ft. I never needed to go lower than this in the So. Fla waters.

After spending a small fortune on my hobbies, I can better understand looking into any sport involving the seas (which I am obsessed about - boating, sailing, SCUBA, reef tanks, whatever) which is "free..." Lame pun, I know.

But more than this, I can appreciate the joy in simplicity, especially the absence of anxiety which involves mastering any complex art that involves personal danger.

As a kid, I snorkeled for years of Miami Beach, Key Biscayne, Pennekamp and I know that this is where my enjoyment really started.

If you stay on the surface, then most people associate it with snorkeling.

Hold your breath and go underwater, and now you are in the realm of freediving.

The first question you then have to ask is, how deep should I go? For me, 20 to 30 feet is fairly easy, on any one breath.

Deeper than that, and it gets tricky. Should you first take several deep breaths, before you finally hold it? Should someone else be watching you from the surface? How deep should you go? Those are all the tricky questions.

Yes, youre free, free of scuba tanks or free of a hookah unit. But with added depth, past 20 or so feet, you have added concerns and added responsibilities. Not so free.
 

Back
Top Bottom