jaydub:I hear the diving in hawaii isnt all that great, but I have never been diving there so dont know from first hand experience. Although I am tempted to visit hawaii as I just found RT airfare to the big island for $326, but hotel rates are killing any chances of me going unfortunately
Hotel rates are not that bad unless you are into staying at the resort hotels that sit on a beach. Get away from the resorts and you will discover a whole other Hawaii.
Royal Kona Resort and King Kamehameha's Kona Beach Hotel are good ones and the rates arent too bad. Name brand hotels will wipe you out like the Hilton, Sheraton
and Marriott.
You can get rooms as low as $70/night, I have done it often.
I rent my 1500 sq ft condo at $120 night and its better than any hotel.
I am not trying to sell my condo but make a point, There are many myths about hawaii.
Also check out www.vrbo.com, thats where I advertise my place and there are many options. Condo's are ALMOST ALWAYS better priced than Hotels and have more room.
As or the diving, Personally, I like the diving there. Its very diferent from the Caribbean in a good way. Its all subjective. Maybe others can pipe in on Hawaii's diving.