OP
Cher4Scuba
Registered
I've stayed at Buddy Dive, Divi and Plaza and would rank them in that order.
Plaza is very spread out and the shore dive site, although a good dive, is a long way from the dive shop and most of the rooms.
Divi is easy access to the house reef from most rooms and the shop and dive pier are near each other.
At Buddy Dive, rooms, dive shop, pier and house reef are all close and IMO, the house reef is a better dive site than Divi.
The only downside to BD, is that you have to drive into town, whereas Divi and Plaza are walking distance.
All 3 have excellent dive ops and good boats.
Hi Doctorfish: Thank you for the ranking and opinion! Doing more research right now. Going to check into Buddy Dive's oceanfront rooms and ratings on their food. We usually don't get a car and if we can't walk to restaurants, want to make sure Buddy's food is OK. I'd like to try their house reef. Thank you for replying!!!