May I introduce myself?
I did such a trip a year ago or so. We went south, around the most southerly point and back up (El Islolte) diving three tanks on our way back around, finishing at Palancar Gardens. SIs were done on the boat, as I recall. According to my log, 1st dive was 21% to 105 ft. for 50 minutes, second dive after a 1 hr. 10 minute SI was to 62 feet for 66 minutes on 32% nitrox and 3rd dive was to 57 feet for 85 minutes on 32% nitors after a 2 hr. 15 minutes SI. Scubawife, please correct if I have this wrong as you were on the same boat.
While I agree this isn't a "normal" profile, it's not beyond the pale with ops that offer big tanks (which include nitrox tanks) or unlimited bottom time. In fact, more like the norm.