Quarry diving is better than no diving! I've made plenty at Willow Springs and Dutch Springs. Agree with just about all the previous comments.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
It’s my closest option to practice, I live in London. If I want to go to the sea, the closest is Brighton/Newhaven and that’s more than 2:30 hours awaySo, I've been watching YouTube videos about diving in quarries, and I don't get it. A few of them have some fish, and some algal mats, but certainly not to the extent that I have seen in, say, Fishing With Luiza's snorkel trip in a river. Mostly, what I see is abandoned cars and other land-based junk, like visiting an underwater junkyard. If everything I can see in a quarry dive is something I can also see in a junkyard on land, why would I go to the trouble of diving there? What have I missed in these videos?
Clearly now, the rain was gone indeed. Stellar vis.
This is what it looks like in April. Camera work isn't so good, but you get the idea. If you watch carefully, you can see the rare Hollis Explorer in action!
What you've missed in the videos is the experience, the practice, the learning, the extending of a person's diving repertoire/abilities.
I get it though, I really do. Until last year I had no desire to dive "cold" or "low vis" or "no fish/coral" dives. Last year I decided to "deal with it" at the local quarry because I wanted to take some classes and didn't want to take a vacation for that purpose, so I ended up at the local quarry. It was late fall, so water temps were up in the 70's at the surface, but in the 40's once you got deep, so I surely wasn't looking forward to that, having only dived tropical waters or Florida springs (a minimum 5 hour drive away) type diving previously. What I found diving there for the classes and for fun was that I became a better diver.
Agreed, agreed. You and I (and @Rollin Bonz) all go to the same quarry, and for really the same reasons. Practice, practice, practice, and there's always a challenge available.
In particular, I like the challenge of being able to go deep; since the bottom goes to and beyond recreational limits, and it's dark down there, I can putz around and get quality experience that will feed into tech diving. And on top of that, the management doesn't fuss about solo diving, as long as you've got your Self-Reliant card on file. In this case, quarry diving is quite the win.
If you are an ocean person there's no answer to your question.