Picked up my Halcyon Eclipse a week and a half ago, and last night I was able to get in the pool with it for the first time and check out what this was going to be like. I went with my dive buddy and his wife. They used the LDS equipment (standard rental gear) that was included in the pool session.
First impression was it didn't seem all that heavy. I got the SS bp, and I figured I'd still need a few pounds of lead. The last time I did dive, I dove with 24 pounds and no wetsuit. I knew I was way overweighted, so this time I took the time to check it out properly. Imagine my surprise when I realized I didn't need a weight belt at all!
I'm a super happy camper on this issue.
Assembling the kit was easy. Nothing really different. Two cambands make for a secure fit, but I had issues getting the bands tight. It appeared I couldn't get a solid grip. So I went and dove with the tank "loose", but sure enough, it held just fine. Just my own jitters. Oh, and the steel cambands didn't scratch the painted tanks, either (per another thread). Might be because I still feel it's a bit loose...
Putting on the wing took me a little time, but only because I did it in the water and the belt straps have a tendency to float into hidden areas behind me. I'll get that under control with practice. However, compared to the other two who were putting on jackets, I did it all myself and in half the time they took.
The LDS fitting wasn't right. The crotch strap was way too long, and the shoulders a bit tight once I was underwater and underway. Not bad, it was livable, but I'll need to tweak it a bit.
I bought the 40# wing because I intend to dive locally wet with single steel tanks. I did experience a bit of taco effect, but at 15' I didn't feel the need to use it to compensate. The whole setup was very streamlined, and comfortable underwater. My buddies' bcs were floating up and away from them, but mine stayed right were it belonged, tight and secure.
After this experience, I am totally sold on this kit. I don't expect I'll ever go back to a jacket bc. To anyone who is afraid of getting into something you won't like, relax. A bp/w is everything they said it would be.
Thanks for reading.