jrmdad, see my post here for very recent feedback on the Roatan Aggressor:
So... Is the Roatan Aggressor
Long story short, it's a terrific boat. But if you're picking among among the three locations listed in your poll, I'd lean towards T&C. The T&C Explorer was also a great boat when I was on it about 5 years ago, and I preferred T&C diving to Roatan diving. But honestly, both are great options and you can't really go wrong. I've been in the Bahamas too, but never Tiger Beach.
So... Is the Roatan Aggressor
Long story short, it's a terrific boat. But if you're picking among among the three locations listed in your poll, I'd lean towards T&C. The T&C Explorer was also a great boat when I was on it about 5 years ago, and I preferred T&C diving to Roatan diving. But honestly, both are great options and you can't really go wrong. I've been in the Bahamas too, but never Tiger Beach.