Is This A Scubapro Mkv First With 109 Second?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

guruboy

Divemaster
ScubaBoard Supporter
Scuba Instructor
Divemaster
Messages
5,180
Reaction score
844
Location
Palo Alto,CA
Picked this up along with some other neat old stuff.

Metal yoke stamped 3000 psi. 2HP and 4LP on a swivel (maybe a 5th on the bottom).

Metal second stage with adjustment knob marked "balanced adjustable".

From what I can tell, this seems to be a MkV first with a 109 second?

IMG_9843.JPG
IMG_9844.JPG
 
Last edited:
plastic yoke saddle....

upload_2016-4-11_16-51-18.png
 
Cool. Thanks.

Read a lot about how MkV are very reliable. How does this compare?
 
the mk-10 is a good stage, and the basis for many other regs by other manufacturers (probably the most copied of all regulators). some feel that the smaller piston was a mistake by SP compared to the mk-5. I've owned 10's for a long time, and never had an issue.
 
The plastic saddle is an easy to spot give away for a Mk 10 versus a Mk 5 with its chrome plated brass saddle.

However the important functional differences are that the Mk 10 uses a smaller diameter piston, and houses the piston and the bearing surfaces in the main body rather than in a separate swivel cap - as is the case on the Mk 5 as well as the later Mk 15, Mk 20 and Mk 25. The larger piston on the Mk 5 (and Mk 15, 20 and 25) also results in a larger size over all.

The Mk 5 evolved a lot over the years getting a swivel cap with 2, 4 and eventually 5 ports, and it also saw the change from 3/8" to 7/16" HP ports and gained a second HP port. In addition the Mk 5 had three different yoke designs - a 2250 psi yoke, a slightly heavier 3000 psi yoke and a much heavier yoke using a 9/16" yoke screw like the Mk 10 and subsequent Scubapro first stages. The Mk 5 also stayed in production and in the catalog along the Mk 10 for much of the Mk 10's production life.

The Mk 5 and Mk 10 both had non swivel turret versions as well for customers who never trusted or wanted the swivel turret cap. The non swivel turret version of the Mk 5 was the Mk 8 and the non swivel cap version of the Mk 10 was the Mk 9.

In both the Mk 5 and Mk 10 you saw style changes in the second stages attached to them with variations in purge covers diaphragms colors and adjustment knobs, and in the last of the Mk 10s you saw a flat, bead blasted finish on the first and second stage, much like the early Mk 20.

----

In the OP's case he has an earlier Mk 10 that has small SPEC holes in the ambient chamber rather than larger holes in a groove designed to accommodate a ring/boot to hold the silicone in.

However, the op has a balanced adjustable second stage that has a later style rubber purge cover and a later G250 style adjustment knob.

The early rubber purge covers had round holes and a very small round lip around the chrome plated brass "S" insert in the center. The next style (the first to appear with the Mk 10) used a raised lip that stuck up about 5/16" around the S and provided more positive purging of the reg. The final style is the one pictured with no lip and oval holes.

The original adjustment knobs on the Adjustable were knurled brass and were solid inside the case, These were followed by knurled brass knobs that will milled in the center to thin the stem inside the case and reduce weight and these were in use when the Balanced Adjustable was introduced. The G250 brought the gear shaped adjustment knobs (like the one in the OP's picture) which are molded plastic over a chrome plated brass stem, and there was a final chrome plated brass gear shaped knob used on the late production Balanced Adjustable as well as the much more recent G250V.

In the case of the OPs reg you'd have to look at the serial number to determine if it is an older second stage sold with its original Mk 10 but with some later replacement parts, or a later second stage paired with an older Mk 10 sometime well after the two were sold. Not that it makes any functional difference. All of them can be updated to the same status and all of them can use the current S-wing poppet, orifice, etc.
 
the mk-10 is a good stage, and the basis for many other regs by other manufacturers (probably the most copied of all regulators). some feel that the smaller piston was a mistake by SP compared to the mk-5. I've owned 10's for a long time, and never had an issue.

It's hard to say for sure, but I'm fairly certain there were more clones of the Mk 5 than the Mk 10. Both were fine regulators. The larger piston offers some mechanical advantages that theoretically make it more responsive, but on the other hand the smaller piston was lighter, which also helps improve response rate. And the later Mk 10 pistons and in particular the Mk 10 Plus piston and seat designs allowed for pretty impressive performance even by a modern standard.

Some of us argued for years with Scubapro to produce a modern equivalent of the Mk 10 - a piston first stage that was significantly lighter, smaller and cheaper than the Mk 25. They've finally done it with the Mk 21, although it's arguably more of a modern version of the Mk 9 than the Mk 10.

Still, it's arguably the best bang for the buck that Scuabpro offers in a first stage and it's a great reg whether it's paired with a G260, and S560 or a C350.
 
Cool. Thanks.

Read a lot about how MkV are very reliable. How does this compare?

In terms of raw numbers the Mk 10 performed better than the Mk 5, particularly, at low tank pressures, and the Mk 10 Plus with the ported piston design, rounded seating edge and concave seat flowed even more gas. (and if you can find the kits you can still upgrade a Mk 10 to a Mk 10 Plus).

Subjectively, however they all breath the same and you just won't notice any differences between them.
 

Back
Top Bottom