I separate my weight between my BCD and my weight belt, I use 18 lbs., 6 in each weight pocket and 6 on my weight belt. I have lost one of my weight pouches at depth, 33% of what I was carrying and did not shoot to the surface. I swam a quite a bit crooked but still stayed down.
Once at the surface I could not redescend without that 6 lbs., but that showed me that it's good to have your weight distributed so that if you lose one of them (which happens, at least with the BCD I have) you won't shoot to the surface.
By the way, I dive cold water in about 12mm of wetsuit protection, 18 pounds isn't too much.