Mike_S you beat me to it about the downtown ferry. I actually much prefer taking that one over Red Hook if I can catch it in time. After the long flight down, that last thing I want to do is sit in a stuffy cab/van travelling to Red Hook to catch the ferry there. Even if it take slightly longer (and I'm not sure it does) I'd still rather be sitting on the top deck of a ferry taking in the sun and checking out the beautiful water.
I've been to St. John/St. Thomas about a dozen times (actually got married on Hawk's Nest beach). Stayed on St. Thomas the first trip and St. John every trip thereafter.
St. John = quite, laid back, relax mon it's island time, no nightlife at all
St. Thomas = more touristy, shopping, bigger, more "resorts"
Really depends on what you like in a vacation.
I've been to St. John/St. Thomas about a dozen times (actually got married on Hawk's Nest beach). Stayed on St. Thomas the first trip and St. John every trip thereafter.
St. John = quite, laid back, relax mon it's island time, no nightlife at all
St. Thomas = more touristy, shopping, bigger, more "resorts"
Really depends on what you like in a vacation.