There are a number of recommendations here for places in the Caribbean & we would add Roatan & the Bay islands to that list for your consideration. We just had guests join us on their honeymoon in June, they spent a week in Roatan's West End at a great little hotel we recommended to them called Cocolobo, then a week with us on a liveaboard diving & sailing trip aboard Zeppelin, and then a week in Utila at Deep Blue Resort. They posted a short review on Scubaboard, have a look under samsitzman.
You can also find lots of other posts that I have made with info about Roatan & the Bay Islands on Scubaboard or take a look at our website
Zeppelin Dive & Sail | Roatan Live Aboard Sailing & Diving Charters for info about both Roatan & what we do. If we can help with any info about Roatan or the Bay Islands feel free to email us at
zeppelinsail@gmail.com, even if you're not interested in our services we would more than pleased to help in any way that we can.
All that being said, you may know this already but in case you don't you should be aware that October is the rainy season in all of the Caribbean, Central America, Mexico etc. and in fact for most of those places it is also potentially hurricane season. It's also rainy season for pretty much anywhere in the tropics in the northern hemisphere for that matter. You may find this is not the best month to be planning this trip in this area in terms of weather. There is a great website
Weather for Over 4,000 Holiday Destinations around the World that provides monthly average climate data with average temperatures, rainfall, humidity levels, water temp etc. for most anywhere in the world, it's an excellent planning tool.
Good luck with your decision, you certainly have lots of choices!