Thanks for all the suggestions thus far!! I will look into Belize and Turks.
We don't want to go to a place like Bonaire or on a Liveaboard only for the fact that those are all diving all the time. We want to find a place with good food, great rooms and views and nightlife. Out of the 10-14 days we are going to go, we will probably dive 5-7 days....so basically half the days diving and the other half being served drinks on the beach.
I have enough airline miles to get me anywhere in the world, hence our thoughts on Thailand, but a really nice Caribbean island we would be open to as well.
I don't know what to do! LOL Good thing we don't get married until October 2014.
14 days in the Caribbean gives you the ability for 2 different islands or combining a live aboard with a separate land trip. With that many days, you might get bored if you stayed in one place the whole time.
Belize and Turks are perfect to split 14 days. Take a look at Belize live aboard diving and mainland non diving if you like interesting topside activities tours. Turks & Caicos live aboard and Provo's beautiful beaches to relax and be served.
For non live aboard Caribbean combinations:
Bonaire-Aruba
Cozumel-Playa Del Carmen
Saba-St. Maarten