Innovation in diving

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Total distance traveled is less of an issue than penetration distance, IMO. Would I have done the dive? Probably not. Not the one he did. But I'm also not apt to find myself in that situation at all because I have a spare bottom timer (stored in a different location than my primary), and I have buddies that also have spares. I'm in a different boat. I'm still not crystal clear on if the "new section" was new to him or new to the configuration. That could change my perception a bit. But if it was a short look into a new area that was surveyed, and I had a decent amount of knowledge about, I can see how it's at least someone reasonable to take a sneak peak. If this info was stated and I missed it, I apologize.

I just think hunk the whole thing is not a huge hairy deal. There are way more important things to have epic long threads about than if someone had a bottom timer on a shallow dive. It's inconsequential given the parameters, from what I see. But I'm open to other conclusions, of course.

one thing I think we all can agree on is that it's a bad idea to post it on an open forum.
 
He included that information on the first page.
"Went in 600 meters, then back out 400 meters, then back in 200 meters, then back out 200 meters, then recovered the jump line, then around and about here and there within 250 meters of the entrance, then went exploring a line the very last bit (leading to a small dry chamber) I never dared to follow before with the rebreather due to size/buoyancy considerations, and then got out (having had more fun than if I had done my otherwise planned exploration rebreather dive for the day).

Pertaining to a map is one thing but doing it for the first time is different.
 
In a nut shell we have you doing a dive without any means of counting for depth or bottom time. OK, not problems here. Your life, your dive. You diving without a means of counting for depth and bottom time and posting about where we have new divers reading about it is another situation all together.

I knew the depth because there is a cave line and the cave line is surveyed and verified and personally dived that run in that cave 400+ times.

I knew the time because I know the time it takes to run from waypoint to waypoint in that run in that cave whether it is by scootering, swimming, or crawling through the silt. Time need not be accurate because there no deco requirement can be incurred in that run in that cave on the available gas. A knowledge of time was only necessary to make sure I was not in a SPG stuck situation.

New divers can understand that, and furthermore can get a glimpse at the importance of a cave line in a cave, and in any event can learn at par with me about a mistake I made, if I made one.

I could have miscalculated that dive, that day, but I did not.

In that cave that dive that day to have or not to have a Dive Computer/Bottom Timer was inconsequential/immaterial.

---------- Post added February 2nd, 2014 at 02:27 AM ----------

one thing I think we all can agree on is that it's a bad idea to post it on an open forum.

Why not post it?

It was pertinent to a different thread where I originally posted it as it was an example of a calculated risk.

---------- Post added February 2nd, 2014 at 02:29 AM ----------

If you truly believed that, you would never use a computer or bottom timer. If you don't need it, why do you ever carry it?

Pure nonsense.

I carry it because I need to know depth and time and in 99.999% of the situations without one I cannot know depth and time.

This was a particular situation because the cave was surveyed with a line and I dived that run 400+ times (depth and times won't change and would be known for that run).

---------- Post added February 2nd, 2014 at 02:33 AM ----------

He included that information on the first page.
"Went in 600 meters, then back out 400 meters, then back in 200 meters, then back out 200 meters, then recovered the jump line, then around and about here and there within 250 meters of the entrance, then went exploring a line the very last bit (leading to a small dry chamber) I never dared to follow before with the rebreather due to size/buoyancy considerations, and then got out (having had more fun than if I had done my otherwise planned exploration rebreather dive for the day).

Pertaining to a map is one thing but doing it for the first time is different.

As explained, it was a line going into a dry chamber.

Really no big deal to follow a line to surface into a dry chamber (if you enter the chamber carefully at the right angle not to dislodge mud/stones...).

It is exploring (visually) a dry chamber, but the line goes from a known point at a known depth to another known point at a known depth (surface)... about 20 meter run at a 70 degree angle beginning at 10 meters and ending at 0 meters.

Worse case I was at surface off-gassing - a non-risk relative to having no Dive Computer/Bottom Timer that day.

P.S. "Turtle Nest" is just a name I made up to get you off from repeating asking for information you won't get... call it innocent disinformation!
 
.....


P.S. "Turtle Nest" is just a name I made up to get you off from repeating asking for information you won't get... call it innocent disinformation!

Which coincidentally is how most folks think about the rest of your threads and diving.
 
Which coincidentally is how most folks think about the rest of your threads and diving.

Fine with me if it makes them happier and sleep better at night...

Were you bullied at school when you were little (maybe I asked before)?
 
Fine with me if it makes them happier and sleep better at night...

Were you bullied at school when you were little (maybe I asked before)?


It's not bullying to point out those that spread nonsense so rabidly and publicly. It's a civic duty.
 
It's not bullying to point out those that spread nonsense so rabidly and publicly. It's a civic duty.

Then do your civic duty and help Tony explain what emergency a Dive Computer/Bottom Timer (which I forgot in the garage...) could have resolved or prevented that time that day (or allow me to express my opinion and that is you are behaving like a common internet bully).
 
Then do your civic duty and help Tony explain what emergency a Dive Computer/Bottom Timer (which I forgot in the garage...) could have resolved or prevented that time that day (or allow me to express my opinion and that is you are just a common internet bully).


The emergency would occur if he or anyone chose to dive with you. As to the dive, this has be covered repeatedly and if you need a refresher you can always read your signature line.

Do they let you post on CDF anymore?
 
The emergency would occur if he or anyone chose to dive with you. As to the dive, this has be covered repeatedly and if you need a refresher you can always read your signature line.

Do they let you post on CDF anymore?

See, you are attacking the person, and not addressing the issue, typical of internet bullying.

Please, just ignore me and the thread because you have nothing to contribute.
 
See, you are attacking the person, and not addressing the issue, typical of internet bullying.

Please, just ignore me and the thread because you have nothing to contribute.


sad_clown_by_turorudolf-d5udqv5.jpg



box-of-kleenexkleenex-kleenex-hand-towels-pop-up-box-9-x-105-hygienic-one-1vodup9m.jpg


ujupygu2.jpg
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/teric/
http://cavediveflorida.com/Rum_House.htm

Back
Top Bottom