Missing DM??? Not sure real or not

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

The only times I have ever experienced down currents in Cozumel were on Santa Rosa Wall, and those who stayed close to the wall - within 3' to 5' - never got into the down current. Only those swimming out and away from the wall - 15' to 20' away from the wall was plenty - got caught. And the down current was not very wide - no more than 30-45 feet - so if you just kept going along the wall, you got out of it pretty quickly. I don't like the notion that you should fully inflate your BC - too much risk of rocketing to the surface once you emerge. If you keep your eyes on the top of the wall ahead of you, you can get an idea where the down current is coming - if you see a small canyon on the top of the wall, with sand flowing out away from the wall, that's a pretty good indicator that the current is flowing out from shore, down that canyon, and will take a sharp turn downward when it falls off the wall. If you stay aware of your surroundings, you can probably avoid the down current altogether.
 
It should be a mandatory briefing before diving any wall dive.
I got caught in one once swimming along a shallow reef, at the edge of a wall. Quite a surprise, and I had left my pony on the boat because of the shallow plan. Now I take it on every dive.
 
I was caught briefly in a strong downcurrent in Cozumel years ago. It was quite a surprise, and a good lesson learned.

Me and my wife were diving some wall (sorry, don't remember). With Living Underwater and Jeremy. We were at about 80 feet, just doing the usual stuff, watching the wall and drifting along easy. My wife (and buddy) was about 5 feet away, Jeremy was probably another 5 feet beyond her.

The first thing I noticed was I got cold. OK, no big deal, a cold spot. Then, suddenly I was surrounded by lots of bubbles (enough to be disorienting) and the bubbles appeared to be rising around me, like there was a diver or two right below me (there may have been, I glanced down but didn't see anyone, I was starting to feel disoriented). Then, quickly, intense pain in my ears. Hmmm. I glanced at my gauge, it showed 100' then I looked around. My wife was still a few feet away, now staring at me with a confused look on her face (and also surrounded by bubbles), and she was pointing to her ears. Yeah, I thought, that's weird, my ears hurt too. I noticed the wall appeared to be going up in front of us. I was just putting 2+2 together (although it was dawning on me more slowly than it should have) when I felt a firm tug on my BCD. Jeremy had grabbed me, I turned to look at him, he had my wife by her BC in his other hand. Our eyes met, I could read his expression (hey, idiot...). We all started finning - no extra air added to our BCDs - and we quickly popped out of it, around 115 feet. Released by the downcurrent (and then released by Jeremy) we all checked ourselves and gave the OK, and started finning up slowly, leveled off again about 80 feet and continued the dive (warily).

It was an odd experience. This was the only time I can ever remember while diving when I felt completely out of control, if only for a moment - we were definitely just along for the ride until we popped out of it. The downward surge was extremely powerful (obviously, in retrospect), one of those moments when you realize how big and powerful natural forces are, and how small and powerless you are by comparison. My impression of the experience was primarily of the odd sensation of being in dense bubbles rising up from below (at least I thought they were rising - I may have just been sinking but the hydrodynamics didn't make sense at the time). The most obvious manifestation was the sudden and intense need to equalize when I hadn't expected to - that was the unmistakeable giveaway.

I think I was in the process of understanding what was happening, and was about to take corrective action when Jeremy snapped me to attention. But I can easily see how one could get caught in one of these and be distracted by the changing conditions - cold water, disoriented by the bubbles and odd sensations, and I can imagine that one might focus first on the pain and the need to equalize - if one remained distracted for very long, you could easily find yourself very deep very quickly. I was glad we were diving with an experienced, savvy, trustworthy DM that day.

I like to think I would know better next time. I've been in relatively minor downcurrents since then (Indonesia) and was ready to swim away at an angle and/or add some air to my BCD, but never have run into anything as strong since.

Being aware of your surroundings and what's going on around you is always important. A basic truth re-confirmed that day.
 
It's been a few years but didn't that dive shop/op owner 'Opal' and friends get 'bent' and/or perish as the result of a down current event ?
Explanation:

After the incident, the story was initially put out that they were caught in a down current, but eventually the truth came out. They had intentionally planned a bounce dive to 300 feet, but at 300 feet Opal kept going deeper. It was probably due to narcosis. The DM caught up with her at about 400 feet and turned her around. The 3rd diver had fortunately stayed shallower, so when they were ascending nad Opal and the DM ran out of air, they were able to do 3 person buddy breathing.

No down currents were involved.
 
Downwellings are not to be taken lightly. Ive been in a few in Coz, most were not that bad. The last one took us down from 65' to 140" extremely quick. If you are diving Cozumel, take it upon yourself to do a bit of studying. Could possibly save your life.
 
No. That was offered as a cause for a bit, but was soon dismissed.
They got bent/perished due to stupidity. There would be kinder, more diplomatic ways to put it, but I'm not inclined to put lipstick on pigs.


Not only that but it caused unneeded fear about diving in Cozumel. I have only been in one such event but it was interesting and easily dealt with. Frankly, I wish that I could have gone through it a time or two more knowing that it was there.
 
Downwellings are not to be taken lightly. Ive been in a few in Coz, most were not that bad. The last one took us down from 65' to 140" extremely quick. If you are diving Cozumel, take it upon yourself to do a bit of studying. Could possibly save your life.

@Gdog, how quickly would you estimate?
 
@Gdog, how quickly would you estimate?

With our down current at Santa Rosa Wall we went from 70' to 125' in just a few seconds. Not sure if I still have the dive profile of it or not. Not a pleasant experience
 
With our down current at Santa Rosa Wall we went from 70' to 125' in just a few seconds. Not sure if I still have the dive profile of it or not. Not a pleasant experience
Not pleasant, but handleable. Back to the original subject: I agree with Dave D that a downwelling in and of itself is unlikely to be the sole cause of the loss of an experienced Cozumel DM.
 
With our down current at Santa Rosa Wall we went from 70' to 125' in just a few seconds. Not sure if I still have the dive profile of it or not. Not a pleasant experience

Thanks @lthomas. Spending quite a bit of time on walls over several hundred feet of water Ill do some reading on how to identify conditions and escape should the need arise. Apologies for the thread drift, and condolences to the young man's family.
 

Back
Top Bottom