... By that logic anytime you disassemble a regulator you have to rebuild it.
You would be correct in your assumption. I follow manufacturers guidlines to a tee. Will a brand new reg fail if all orings are not replaced ? maybe maybe not- Im not willing to take that chance with my customer's life. If I am going to pull a reg apart that I have no previous dealings with, its a rebuild.
...I just don't see the danger or disadvantage you would like to have folks believe exists in buy regulators and other scuba gear on the internet (including used gear). .
Um, Defective oring? Leaking 1st stage is not safe..? Stright out of the box.