I love this contribution. Especially after reading 6,344,297 scuba board posts to new divers saying they should buy expensive stuff to start since they may decide later to take up tech diving.
I would argue that this is typical of many new divers or older confirmed non tech divers like myself.
While I COMPLETELY understand the "Don't buy it twice" mentality (keeping salt water aquariums for any length of time will teach you that) I'd prefer to have the OPTION of purchasing a "cheaper" model to start with. Every store I go in says "this is what you need" without actually listening to my wants, desires, diving style, frequency, etc.
You don't get it. The cheap stuff doesn't have to be upgraded. It's just as good.
First, +1
@Steve_C. I see SB posts urging high end purchases far more than ones urging reasonably priced equipment. Often they say the low(er) end gear is junk. Bushwah.
Second, +1
@Scuba-Blue-13. I have a habit of researching what I want to buy intensively. Not just scuba gear but everything. Most often, when I ask my LDS if thay carry or can get a specific brand and model they try to direct me to something they prefer or sell. Guess what - I want what I want - not an argument. They also often try to get me to switch from the way I'm diving to something that costs a lot - at least initially. For example, you really need to learn to dive in a drysuit, you really need to get into sidemount.
Guess what? Single backmount and layering insulation is fine for me. I'm 71, the local diving is pretty poor, and I'm not in the habit of fixing what ain't broke.
Finally, +1
@2airishuman
Before I started OW I researched equipment that I wanted to train with. They included BC, reg set, and computer. I did a thorough job and came up with low end equipment to start with. During my first class the owner of the LDS told me I should have talked to him because he would have recommended different equipment, primarily the BC which was a jacket style. He would have recommended a back inflate. He could have also directed me to a "quality" reg set and a better computer.
Years later, I still prefer the jacket BC - hate back inflate BC's (though for trips I now use a soft backpack and harness sans wing because it packs better), I'm still exclusively using original reg set (though I switched the 2nd stage primary for a Hollis 500SE
solely for the side exhaust), and I would probably still be using the Oceanic Veo 100 if not for my declining eyesight - I got a Mares Icon for the huge display).
I love the Cressi AC2 1st stage. It's rugged, dependable, bullet-proof, and so easy to service. I've had it to 130' and in 42°F water (108') and it performed flawlessly when my buddies high end balanced diaphragm free flowed causing an aborted dive. I've never had occasion to wish I had "better" gear.
In short, there may be a difference between the low end gear and the top of the line - there probably is. It's not a difference I can notice, nor one that I believe is worth the price differential, and certainly not a difference I or every new diver needs. You don't need it till you do. There's time enough to decide to upgrade
IF you decide you need to. Starting with top of the line, bleeding edge equipment is vast overkill for most beginning divers