ScubaSteve1962
Contributor
It is possible that this was OK. the rules say there should be a pool session, but it can be done in the open water in "pool-like conditions." I did my second one in Cozumel, and after the classroom session, we went to a sheltered, shallow area of the ocean right next to the hotel to practice our skills. That is acceptable under the rules.
The problem was when I got in the water I had mask problems, it kept flooding as soon as I put my head under water, and they kept telling me I wasn't clearing it right (now this was my first experience with a mask) it ended up being a faulty mask. We didn't practice any skills, I think the pool sessions help you get more comfortable in the water than just jumping in to the deep blue sea. I do know if I had done it in just a pool situation, I wouldn't be diving today. If any body asks me about diving, I tell them to try DSD where they can get in the ocean. Just seeing the wonders of the sea will let you know if it's for you or not. I just don't think you can get that in a pool.