Feb 19 2017 Cozumel diving fatality

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Who disconnects the inflator hose when they surface?
If your inflator malfunctions and sticks open disconnecting the hose will stop the uncontrolled inflation.

There's not enough information here to make a reasonable best guess at what may have happened. It seems that typically it is a combination of issues.
 
Many things are wrong here. Not checking her bcd surfacing alone etc etc

Not to mention just randomly finding the poor thing on the reef. Was anyone looking for her???
 
Sad news :(

Wonder how long she was there before anyone noticed her missing from a group ? Where was her buddy ? From the limited information wonder if there was a search for her before she was found ?

Divegoose
 
If your inflator malfunctions and sticks open disconnecting the hose will stop the uncontrolled inflation.

There's not enough information here to make a reasonable best guess at what may have happened. It seems that typically it is a combination of issues.
I agree, usually in any accident a series of small mistakes leads to an unfortunate event. If her inflator was stuck open, I would expect her to be stuck at the surface with a full bladder.
 
My condolences to all involved.

Maybe a heart attack, but maybe she would be alive if she was on the boat safely.

This is another reason to dive with a reliable buddy.

Woman loses her life in diving practice




COZUMEL, February 19 .- In tragedy ended what would be the walk of an American family during the morning of this Sunday when they performed the practice of diving in the reefs of Palancar, Gardens, at which time Tammy R. Schmitz suffered from a Infarct, losing their lives in the sea, so that authorities of the Attorney General's Office went to the lifting of the body for the corresponding procedures and to be able to carry out the transfer of the body to its place of origin.
According to information, a report was received at 9-1-1, during the morning of this Sunday, explaining first the loss of a diver; So the indication was issued to the official authorities, although minutes later it was reported that it was a female person who was lifeless on the south coast of the city.
In information, it was revealed that the boat named Gaviota I, of the company Scuba Mau, was doing a diving service with Ricardo Rafael Loeza, 19 years old, who was presumably the guide of the divers, together with Gonzalez Malvaes Liras, captain of the boat, who accompanied the instructor Paulín Fuentes, when the tragedy occurred.
According to information obtained, it transpired that during the dive exercise, Tammy R. Schmitz, 43 years old and originally from Denver, Colorado separated from the group to say she felt bad, so the guide accompanied her five feet before The surface to return by the other members of the tour, being 10 minutes later when the others left the water and noticed that there was no female.
Immediately they entered the sea, finding it lifeless, apparently not presenting vital signs, so they boarded the boat Gaviota I, and approached the nearest pier, a few meters from Palancar beach, where they were asked for access to enter the Paramedics of the International Hospital, in order to be able to attend the companions to corroborate the situation of the female who did not react and confirmed the death.
That is why the State Attorney General's Office, as well as the ministerial police and the Forensic Medical Service, were informed of the incident and then disembarked at the Nachi-Cocom pier, where the unit was waiting for him To make the transfer to the Semefo where the autopsy of law would be carried out to him later to make the delivery of the body to the relatives.
 
Oh dear...so sad for all. I feel for the 19 year old guide, who is probably raking himself over the coals. Terrible judgement error.
 
I wonder why the boat didn't pick her up.

maybe she was already having the heart attack when she indicated she didn't feel well and never surfaced.
 
He was guiding a group of people. One got ill. He took her back up close to the surface and returned to the group. It turned out bad. However, if he would have stayed with her and saw her onto the boat he would have been leaving his group untended and if one of them had drowned folks would have been saying it was bad judgement. The safest thing would be to call the dive and take the whole group to the surface. But that may or may not be shop practice.

Note that rounding up the whole group and getting them all going back up could have taken a lot more time than helping one diver and also delayed her getting to the surface.
 
Leaving the group to fend for themselves is normal though. They weren't in any trouble, they should be able to surface themselves safely as needed. If they can't, then they shouldn't be diving.

Should have waved a thumb at them, and brought her all the way to the surface and to the boat. When the rest don't see the DM for 2 min, they all follow the rule to regroup at the surface. If someone else misses the thumb, then it should also be pretty obvious to surface when everyone's gone.

He chose to give the group more attention than the sick diver, that's a mistake. Then again, she may have indicated to the DM that she was perfectly OK at 5 feet, and that's why he left her to surface on her own. Heart attacks can be sneaky like that.

But still, where was her buddy? Buddy system fails again.
 

Back
Top Bottom