I did a trip with them last year (Bimini itinerary). I had a blast.
Liked it so much, I've booked another trip on them this July (they have some openings two different weeks in July and will likely discount to guarantee a more full boat).
I've done other boats (e.g., Hughes Wind Dancer) and this isn't a Peter Hughes boat. No ensuite bathroom, only a sink. The galley/dining area is small. The sun deck's somewhat small (and has no shaded area for sitting or lying)...heck, the boat's sorta small given how many people they can put on it. It's only got 90 or so feet of beam I think. And no, there's no dive deck clothes dryer from which they grab hot towels and wrap you up as you emerge from a night dive...you have to provide your own towels and dry them as best you can (in the wind stream).
The food's pretty good. I'd give it 2 stars. You never want for food. It's good, basic, stick to the ribs fare. Better than a diner's offerings, no where near what you might get on, say, the MV Wind Dancer. You'll go home with no complaints about the food.
When I went out on the Sea Fever, a majority of the dives were great. I'd say 30% were blah or so so, but part of that's just an issue of what were the sky conditions like, the weather, etc.
Give them a call...
The diving's fun.
I'm going out with them again...