NEW HOG Softpack and comfort harness- initial impressions

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Jim Lapenta

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Divemaster
Messages
18,090
Reaction score
11,586
Location
Canonsburg, Pa
# of dives
1000 - 2499
I have had in my possession now for a couple weeks the new HOG softpack and comfort harness. Along with the 32 lb bungee wing. The first time I had it in the water was during my UW Photo class two weeks ago.

Having been involved with this project from the beginning and providing some of the the hardware designs and prototypes, I am biased. Not going to hide that. Even so those who know me also know that if I don't think something is ok, I won't recommend it.

This I recommend. Is it for everyone? No, it is however going to meet a need that I run into with my students who, for whatever reason, don't want a traditional jacket or a back plate and wing.

The entire assembly is modular and it comes as parts. Webbing, drings, slides, waist belt plates, and buckle. there are also two shoulder pads that are nice but don't have to be used. The harness will also work with the HOG Steel or aluminum plates and probably any other plate out there.

The soft pack is light, and not overly padded. It has just enough let's say. So buoyancy wise it's not a concern. The cam bands slide through webbing secured to the back in the same way as similar styles. I mean c'mon, there are only so many ways to secure webbing on a soft pack so you go with what works. You don't try to reinvent the wheel.

The bungee wing is not fixed. You can remove it if you choose and adjust the tension as well as placement. It does not compress the empty wing as much as some others seem to do. The rig will work with any HOG 23 or 32lb wing with the long slits.

The harness package itself when assembled on the soft pack will adjust from someone say 5'7" and around 150 lbs to something like a 6'7" 300 lb guy. So when you are smaller like me there is some webbing left to trim.

I added the new HOG weight pockets to it in order to distribute my weights. It's been a long time since I had a single al80 in back mount in open water. So back to the log book to get a starting point with my 5 mil merino. The last time I used an al80 and a 5 mil in a non bpw set up was nearly 4 years ago. I needed at the time 16lbs to be properly weighted.

So that's what I started with for the 1st dive. 2lbs in each small pocket on each cam band, 3 in each large pocket on the waist strap, and 6 lbs on my MAKO rubber belt. Did not feel terribly overweighted but felt a bit over. Next dive I swapped the 3's for 2's and had no issues at the end of the dive with 700 psi left in the tank. No trouble holding a stop at 6 ft.

I will try to post some pictures later. Right now the unit is available in this size and a smaller size as well which should work for kids and smaller individuals under say 5'5" and 140lbs. I am going to be using this a bit over the next couple months along with my Sidemount unit. It's comfortable, dives well, and looks good.

There is a bit of a learning curve to setting it up and I recommend that you have your dealer do it if you are not familiar with rigging a harness. I have assembled over 100 BPW's at this point with various harness mods. Even created some custom set ups for people with hardware I manufacture myself.

I needed to follow the instructions on this the first time and, being in a rush, ended up re working it. It offers a lot of options to customize it for fit and placement of the hardware as a traditional BPW and actually adds a level to that.

The waist strap plates slide so that you can make it more of a conventional BPW fit or a "H" style harness that some sidemount systems (including the HOG) make use of. I actually prefer this now due to having a shorter torso that had my back up lights under my arm pits.

If you want more info shoot me an email to jimlap212@comcast.net or call me at the number in my signature line. You can also get in touch with any other HOG dealer about it.
 
If you don't mind going a bit OT and if you know the answer,
  • how bulky are the 5lb pockets (esp. if you have XS scuba ones to compare to) and
  • can they be mounted on shoulder straps?
I find I prefer the weight on the front rather than in the camband pockets, and I carry a couple of 3-4lbs on the shoulder straps. I also find that XSScuba pockets are a bit bulkier than I need for that.
TIA
 
I never mind off topic questions about products I sell. Some do but who is to say what is off topic? You are asking a valid question about a component I mentioned in this review. Therefore it is not off topic.

The smaller pockets are designed to take a 5lb hard or soft weight. Like the XS scuba pockets that I use on my MAKO belt.

So to answer your question, IMO, honestly they would be too large to put on the shoulder straps. I'd post a better pic of them on the cam bands but my rig is packed for a dive trip tomorrow morning. You can kind of get an idea from this. The large pocket is on the waist strap. Small on each cam band threaded quickly. I am going to move them so they sit up against the soft pack on either side.

I have a student that uses the other pocket I sell, but am out of now, to add 2 lbs to each shoulder on his sidemount rig. They work for that but if he were to put more in them they would accommodate it since they are also made for a 5lb weight.

There is another that may work for your purpose. You'd have to unthread the harness to install it, but Piranha sells a small accessory pocket that a 4lb hard weight just fits in.

Accessory-Weight-Pouch

I sell them also but get them from Piranha myself so you wouldn't save any money getting them from me.




circleville70216 093.JPG
 
Thank you. I was thinking of making something out of a piece of 2" webbing, a few weight keepers, and some velcro (and parents' antique Singer that can stitch through boiled leather), but at $7 the Piranha pouch's worth trying. Thanks again.
 
I would be interested in seeing more photos here Jim!
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom