Bubbletrubble
Contributor
@Diver0001: You describe the broad framework set up by PADI standards as something that affords instructors the creativity to "look for efficient ways to get things done." I think there's a tendency for some instructors (how many?) to use this creative wiggle room to get things done quickly, rather than in a manner that benefits the student. We can talk all we want about re-writing standards so that the minimum acceptable performance is raised, but in the end, I think the problem lies in the fact that some people show an inherent aptitude for teaching and some don't. Some people possess that special gift of being able to help guide different students with various personalities to proficiency, whereas others are busy checking off boxes on a dive slate. Some people are always looking for ways to improve instructional methods, whereas some don't. I don't know whether such natural deficiencies in teaching are tractable via mentoring...or whether those people should have been screened out prior to getting certified as instructors in the first place. For better and for worse, it's pretty clear that PADI has made significant compromises in maintaining a large corps of instructors throughout the world. In terms of instruction, it appears that the emphasis is on quantity over quality.