Hmm...so the general consensus is split, lol. I'm thinking that I should take the AOW in NE to challenge myself, although I'm thinking it's pretty dark down there at ~ 100ft. I have an outstanding instructor; I just hate the cold water and the dark.
I'll fix that... Do it in New England otherwise it will be a meaningless ritual. Also by doing it locally you have the chance to really select an instructor who will make it a meaningful experience.
If you have local pro aspirations anything else is hypocritical. Nothing says you need to dive the harbor. The next 8-10 weeks offer the seasons best diving so cold should not be a barrier. Limited visibility is reality.
Pete