Widow sues medical doctor and training company

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

This could be taken from a bad crime TV show:
A year ago, Cindy and Tim Burns were supposed to celebrate their 30th wedding anniversary. Cindy had bought her husband scuba diving lessons so he'd be ready for their trip to Hawaii.

Anyone see the irony of purchasing the scuba diving lessons for her husband knowing that he has medical issues and then suing when he dies?

Maybe I'm just jaded.
 
It sounds like the victim already had one foot in the grave and the other on a banana peel to me. You don't get emphysema and an enlarged heart overnight. From a lay person stand point, this guy was on his way to checking out and had no business doing anything strenuous.

And his wife gave him SCUBA lessons...


Bob
-------------
Don't look behind the curtain.
 
Class 1 Poop show in my backyard. WTF ever happened to personal responsibility?
Normally I completely agree with personal responsibility and assumption of risk. And if he omitted or lied on the form then this applies. But if he was forthcoming with his and symptoms then at that point the responsibilty lies with the provider to do an accurate and complete evaluation and discussion with the diver. We have no way to know if this was done.
 
The dive shop missed the mark if they did in fact see him symptomatic, and if he had to abort the dive to use an inhaler I have to assume he was, then let him continue without at least some additional investigation of his control and tolerence to diving.

I agree completely with this.

Over my time teaching (about 2500 certs of various levels) I "only" lost one student... and it was an oddball situation.

On the first night of a "Basic" NAUI course, I was caught in a massive snow storm and was not going to be able to get back to the town where the course was being held. I called an Instructor friend and asked if she could cover for me. After the roads reopened, I made it home at about 11 PM. My phone was ringing as I came in. It was my girlfriend (and recent AI graduate). She was very upset and advised that one of the new students had died in the pool! During the "watermanship evaluation" in the pool, staff noticed this guy at the bottom of the pool during the water-tread bit. They dragged him out, began CPR. The fire station was right next door, and EMS was there in about 4 minutes. They carted him away, but he was pronounced on arrival at the hospital.

I never met this man but he was 42, played tennis several times a week and was a regular runner. From what I was told he was of average build and by all accounts, fit and healthy.

There was an inquest of course, and when the Coroner delivered his report on the autopsy, he advised that of this guys cardiac arteries were almost completely blocked. Cause of death was a massive heart attack. He died so fast, he didn't even have time to drown! The coroner went on to say that this man almost certainly would have died shovelling snow the next morning.

At that point, the family's lawyers closed their notebooks and left.

I should add that the gentleman who died was a Doctor.... an orthopaedic specialist I believe.

My point in this is that sometimes people aren't aware of what's wrong with them, or perhaps they are in denial.

I recall attending a seminar at a NAUI conference towards the end of my teaching time, and being told that we needed to be brutally honest about the risks with diving with students right at the beginning of the course. While we had them sign waivers, the NAUI lawyer basically said that in order for a waiver to be legit, the person signing it needs to be aware of the risks and well informed. Prior to this blunt warning we were to deliver, a new student couldn't possible be aware of the risks in diving simply because he wasn't a diver. The only exposure a new student had to diving was likely the fancy posters and brochures at the dive shop and ads in magazines. All sunshine and pretty fish.

As Instructors, we were told that out first class was to begin something like this: "Hi, I'm Stoo and I will be your diving instructor. Thanks for coming. I must tell you something about this awesome sport however... On occasion, people die while they are diving. Usually there's an obvious cause, but not always. Sometimes divers can be doing everything right, and they might still die. It's unlikely, but you might have any one of the following 18 things go wrong..." And then list everything from shark bites to boat strikes to IPEs, embolisms to DCS. Oddly, nobody ever got up and left, but it became pretty common to lose a few by the second night of the course.

Anyway, my point is that a new student is often completely in the dark about diving, and in some cases, their health as well. And some are in denial. It's incumbent on shops and Instructors and Doctors who are doing medicals to do their jobs properly. Failure to do so will result in people getting hurt, or worse. Shops are unfortunately faced with economic factors with trying to fill classes, and are undoubtedly lowering the bar beyond the point of good sense, in favour of trying to make a little money.

How many shops have taken "morbidly obese" people into classes knowing full well that that person is at increased risk for any number of things? Or non-swimmers, or heavy smokers? And how many students are less than honest with their medical histories? I suspect it's a large percentage, especially as the average entry age to the sport has climbed to the point where we must be competing primarily against lawn-bowling leagues for business.
 
Last edited:
Darwin selection at its best :rofl3:! All of them are at fault.:rant: Now 9 million $ for an idiot - enlarge heart, asthma,, pneumonia and for a Dr in dentistry :rolleyes: - That can only happen in the US :):flagwaving::clapping:

Your empathy is astounding. Calling him an "idiot" is uncalled for.

It's typical to suit for a much larger amount then you expect or even hope to get. A Dentist makes a good living, so they would be looking at the cost of being denied his income for his working life etc.

And no, I am not American.
 
This could be taken from a bad crime TV show:

Anyone see the irony of purchasing the scuba diving lessons for her husband knowing that he has medical issues and then suing when he dies?

Maybe I'm just jaded.

Hahaha, the article didn't say if the wife was a diver, just that she bought him lessons. Makes one wonder if she did it hoping something would happen. He was 51 and she would be roughly the same age. His health was not good, if she planned it, then things are working out, he's gone, dentists make good money so I'm sure they were fairly comfortable, and now she has a lottery ticket (lawsuit) for a windfall. 50 is still young, I bet you a dollar her new love interest is much younger! LOL
 
Your empathy is astounding. Calling him an "idiot" is uncalled for.
.

Emphysema, enlarged hearth and asthma. If you are in the medical profession and you still want to dive, you should expect that the worse can happen. I have a personnal friend that has emphysema, an enlarged hearth, a pacemaker and a defibrilator. The doctor have signed him for diving but frankly he knows that he can die, diving. So does his wife. It is just a personnal choice. He is not in the medical profession and he is fully aware of it. .So your example, with asthma above it, should know and if he does not, yes, he is an idiot.

P.S. I see that you say you are not an American. Did Canada move recently :giggle:
 
...I have a personnal friend that has emphysema, an enlarged hearth, a pacemaker and a defibrilator. The doctor have signed him for diving but frankly he knows that he can die, diving. So does his wife. It is just a personnal choice. He is not in the medical profession and he is fully aware of it. .So your example, with asthma above it, should know and if he does not, yes, he is an idiot. ...

The problem is if/when an issue occurs as your friend is diving, it's likely not just him that will be affected. If he's on a boat, in a group or with a buddy, they would at the very least be traumatized & at the worst could lose their own lives trying to save him. Even if he dives alone, rescue workers could still put their lives at risk trying to save him.

I understand how much it sucks to have to give up diving short-term (as I have had to do) or forever, but it's just not cool to put others at risk.
 
My guess is that most of the above will be revealed in the lawsuit. Better to be tried in a court of law than the court of public opinion on SB. This makes me (an immigrant to the US) so much happier with the legal system here. Talk about his widow taking up with a younger guy and "windfalls" is abhorrent and tasteless.
 
Why are you guys focusing on medical issues that are generally not considered to be a contradiction to diving in modern times? The article pretty clearly says it was a mishandled OOA accident. The diver managed to get OOA and the instructor (or other students) didn't have an alternate air source for him? Did a whole class of divers manage to dive with no octo?

Seems straightforward to me. The instructor screwed up -one way or another. He didn't teach/assist with air monitoring and apparently had no alternate air source. Why the discussion about asthma when the article doesn't say he died from asthma?
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/peregrine/

Back
Top Bottom