Columbia !!! It always delivers...
from my log ....
"We descended onto Columbia reef. The DM spotted a turtle at the end of the first swim thru. Yay, a turtle! I looked from the turtle over to a couple of big-a$$ groupers and saw a GIANT green moray eel appear, freely swimming, looking for shelter. OH WOW !! Then, as I rose up over the coral head, there was a big eagle ray swimming over the top at the same time, closer than I've ever seen. By this time I'm shrieking in my reg I'm so excited. Had to take a moment to calm down so I didn't suck all my air since all this happened in the first 10 minutes or so. A day to remember. "
For a shallow dive: The Gardens of Ixchel with DM Victor Brito. Also... it's overrun and a cliche but Paradise is a beautiful dive. Always find my little morays there.