Bonaire, Little Cayman (or Cozumel) for mix of non divers, beginners, and advanced?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

joalemma

Registered
Messages
12
Reaction score
3
Location
Mid Atlantic USA
# of dives
0 - 24
Hello. I am looking for advice on a trip late October, early November to Bonaire, Little Cayman, or "elsewhere: that is an easy flight from the US mainland. There may be a mix of non divers, some of whom may get certified while there, snorkelers with no interest in certification, very beginner divers (me), and a couple of others that do not dive a lot but are definitely more advanced. As a beginner, and more so due to my personality, I would prefer a destination where shallow, "easy" dive sites are easily accessible, preferably where snorkelers could be above us, plus some top side activities, and dive sites for the more advanced. This group is happy with adequate, not necessarily "upscale" accommodations (we do like AC), hopefully calm seas and an abundance of sea life, and a dive shop boasting dives led by DM, as well as instruction and certification opportunities, is a necessity.

Alternatively, if the others choose not to join us, it may just be me and my hubby, and perhaps a brother and another friend, of which all but me have many dives and are overall much more comfortable with scuba diving.

As for myself, I am a self-acclaimed "risk averse, passive" person who was certified years ago yet just now looking at diving as an activity to "age in to". I am a fine swimmer with a healthy fear of water, yet "nervous" about diving as my limited experience was with I felt were "rushed" dives relative to gear set up on rocking boats and descent starting in quite choppy waters, though that's likely due to my personality. I just opted for, and successfully completed, a refresher course in the Florida Keys that was chased with a couple of dives without a DM or instructor, though I had thought the instructor would be with me during the dives. I was assigned a "buddy" for the dives, and both were shallow dives. Fortunately, the instructor for the refresher was an amazing, confidence building instructor and the divers on the boat was made up of a casual, small group of incredibly thoughtful divers, who dive with this "outfit" regularly. Having no DM (which I've always had on my few previous dives) resulted in my learning a great deal about communicating about the dive while on the boat, before descent, just after descent (one diver had to provide me with some of their weight), and continuously throughout the dive (this was a big positive lesson, as I've always just followed a DM). The instructor, who was a mate on the boat, apparently was very cognizant of the groups communication as they commented on such (as well as gently scolded me for not coming back up for my own weight, though happy the other diver and I worked together to adjust my weights while underwater). I was even able to take some group pictures of the other divers as someone had an underwater camera and taught me how to use it while underwater, the communication was that effective (and the dive was that "easy", no current, shallow, very clear waters)! The result of this experience is that I'm ready to dive again because my comfort level has exponentially increased, and it was an overall great experience.

All of the above is to say that if it is just me and my husband, and maybe a couple other advanced divers, I'd prefer to be at a location where the others can go off on advanced dives and I can avail myself to any training opportunity, dives with DM, "easy (shallow, little current, warm, clear, sea life - things we beginners want) and "home" reefs right off the dock or beach, so as to gain more experience, comfort and confidence without the others feeling as if they have to accommodate their wishes and wants for diving to my novice experience.

Thank you in advance for your thoughts on where I may find my unicorn!
 
Little Cayman is not "an easy flight from the US mainland," as you have to change airlines on Grand to get there and risk some issues with Cayman Air (usually fine, but not always). Bonaire checks most of your boxes, including decent house reefs, good boat diving if you want, usually-good viz, and some more advanced diving for those who wish, and a good range of topside activities (mangrove kayaking, hiking, lovely views, excellent bird life). You might also consider St. Croix, which is a beautiful island with lots to do topside, some interesting water experiences (e.g., kayaking through phosphorescence), and a fun waterfront. The reefs there are pretty much kaput, but the Frederiksted Pier is a Class A dive--tons of critters, fishy, shallow dives).
 
Thank you for your reply! We will definitely check out St. Croix. Looking like Bonaire is on top, at least for now.
 
Hello. I am looking for advice on a trip late October, early November to Bonaire, Little Cayman, or "elsewhere: that is an easy flight from the US mainland. There may be a mix of non divers, some of whom may get certified while there, snorkelers with no interest in certification, very beginner divers (me), and a couple of others that do not dive a lot but are definitely more advanced. As a beginner, and more so due to my personality, I would prefer a destination where shallow, "easy" dive sites are easily accessible, preferably where snorkelers could be above us, plus some top side activities, and dive sites for the more advanced. This group is happy with adequate, not necessarily "upscale" accommodations (we do like AC), hopefully calm seas and an abundance of sea life, and a dive shop boasting dives led by DM, as well as instruction and certification opportunities, is a necessity.

Alternatively, if the others choose not to join us, it may just be me and my hubby, and perhaps a brother and another friend, of which all but me have many dives and are overall much more comfortable with scuba diving.

As for myself, I am a self-acclaimed "risk averse, passive" person who was certified years ago yet just now looking at diving as an activity to "age in to". I am a fine swimmer with a healthy fear of water, yet "nervous" about diving as my limited experience was with I felt were "rushed" dives relative to gear set up on rocking boats and descent starting in quite choppy waters, though that's likely due to my personality. I just opted for, and successfully completed, a refresher course in the Florida Keys that was chased with a couple of dives without a DM or instructor, though I had thought the instructor would be with me during the dives. I was assigned a "buddy" for the dives, and both were shallow dives. Fortunately, the instructor for the refresher was an amazing, confidence building instructor and the divers on the boat was made up of a casual, small group of incredibly thoughtful divers, who dive with this "outfit" regularly. Having no DM (which I've always had on my few previous dives) resulted in my learning a great deal about communicating about the dive while on the boat, before descent, just after descent (one diver had to provide me with some of their weight), and continuously throughout the dive (this was a big positive lesson, as I've always just followed a DM). The instructor, who was a mate on the boat, apparently was very cognizant of the groups communication as they commented on such (as well as gently scolded me for not coming back up for my own weight, though happy the other diver and I worked together to adjust my weights while underwater). I was even able to take some group pictures of the other divers as someone had an underwater camera and taught me how to use it while underwater, the communication was that effective (and the dive was that "easy", no current, shallow, very clear waters)! The result of this experience is that I'm ready to dive again because my comfort level has exponentially increased, and it was an overall great experience.

All of the above is to say that if it is just me and my husband, and maybe a couple other advanced divers, I'd prefer to be at a location where the others can go off on advanced dives and I can avail myself to any training opportunity, dives with DM, "easy (shallow, little current, warm, clear, sea life - things we beginners want) and "home" reefs right off the dock or beach, so as to gain more experience, comfort and confidence without the others feeling as if they have to accommodate their wishes and wants for diving to my novice experience.

Thank you in advance for your thoughts on where I may find my unicorn!
I just got back from Little Cayman Beach Resort, and I go to Bonaire every year (timeshare at Divi Flamingo Beach). Never been diving in Cozumel, but it is known for drift diving, which in my opinion doesn't match up with your requirements.

Little Cayman has great diving, zero current, but...it's all boat diving - no shore diving and no snorkeling. And there is NOTHING for a non-diver to do. There's no town. One tiny grocery store and one tiny liquor store on the whole island. I'd go back in a heartbeat, but I love 3-a-day boat diving.

Bonaire ticks all your boxes. Warm water, great vis, no current, excellent (easy) shore diving, excellent boat diving if that's your thing. Good snorkeling. Stuff for non-divers to do. If you stay at a good location, you can have an easy, safe walk to town, restaurants and grocery stores. I've only ever stayed at Divi Flamingo Beach. Excellent dive operation. Big 36' Newton Dive Boats with 2 ladders. Boat dives are all led by a divemaster. Shore dives 24x7 from their dock - just grab a tank and go. Bathtub-like water in front of the hotel and a good house reef.

Any questions, I'll try to helpl...
 
I just got back from Little Cayman Beach Resort, and I go to Bonaire every year (timeshare at Divi Flamingo Beach). Never been diving in Cozumel, but it is known for drift diving, which in my opinion doesn't match up with your requirements.

Little Cayman has great diving, zero current, but...it's all boat diving - no shore diving and no snorkeling. And there is NOTHING for a non-diver to do. There's no town. One tiny grocery store and one tiny liquor store on the whole island. I'd go back in a heartbeat, but I love 3-a-day boat diving.

Bonaire ticks all your boxes. Warm water, great vis, no current, excellent (easy) shore diving, excellent boat diving if that's your thing. Good snorkeling. Stuff for non-divers to do. If you stay at a good location, you can have an easy, safe walk to town, restaurants and grocery stores. I've only ever stayed at Divi Flamingo Beach. Excellent dive operation. Big 36' Newton Dive Boats with 2 ladders. Boat dives are all led by a divemaster. Shore dives 24x7 from their dock - just grab a tank and go. Bathtub-like water in front of the hotel and a good house reef.

Any questions, I'll try to helpl...
Wow, definitely sounds like Bonaire is the winner so far. And definitely not Little Cayman. At least for this trip.
 
Wow, definitely sounds like Bonaire is the winner so far. And definitely not Little Cayman. At least for this trip.
Divi Flamingo dock. The water is always this calm in front of the hotel.
IMG_4919.JPG

View from the 2nd floor "Studio" rooms. This is one of 2 pools. The other one is a lot bigger.
IMG_4941.JPG
 
Wow, definitely sounds like Bonaire is the winner so far. And definitely not Little Cayman. At least for this trip.
+1 for Bonaire, based on your criteria. It's not my favorite dive location (mostly because I prefer boat diving to shore diving), but it ticks all your boxes. Have a great trip!
 
+1 for Bonaire, based on your criteria. It's not my favorite dive location (mostly because I prefer boat diving to shore diving), but it ticks all your boxes. Have a great trip!
No requirement to shore dive in Bonaire. Many do mostly boat dives and their house reef.
 
Beware, petty crime in Bonaire is, and always been, out of control. Anything not left in a safe or behind a locked hotel door will get stolen. Do not leave anything unattended in your vehicle, and leave your vehicle unlocked so the thieves don't break a window.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom